Your thoughts on anime.

Wow u got some nice ones on ur list nano desu, I am really glad anytime someone wants to watch Shigofumi, there are a few on ur list that certain users here with tell u to watch and I will agree with them, but I'll let them convince u to make it a priority over others, the only other one on ur list that I urge you to watch is Eureka Seven, other than that I could suggest moar, but a genre that u like could help narrow down ideas nano desu

Hm...decent list, but what have you already watched before that? I can make a few suggestions. For romance/comedy type anime I would try Mahoromatic, Raimuiro Senkitan, or definitely Ai Yori Aoshi if you haven't seen it. Something more actiony...maybe Noir (A bit slow paced, but the music is good and the plot develops nicely), or Scrapped Princess (Underrated.). Then again, maybe it's time you got into mystery and crime, a good starter there would be Tantei Gakuen Q. Good stuff. Oh and since you like School Rumble, you need to see Azumanga Daioh.

I'm curious, what animes have you already seen? Depending on what you seen or not I can recommend some.

elfen lied is pretty messed up but still good, eureka seven is a classic anime love story and claymore is easily one of the best looking animes i have ever seen

From the ones you mentioned, I'd prioritize Elfen Lied and School Rumble (completely different shows obviously so it would depend on what you feel like watching ATM).
Claymore is very good for 18-20 episodes so I'd also consider it if you're looking for action and don't mind some gore/disfigurement.
Xam'd: Lost Memories is a series very similar to Eureka Seven, I found far superior. Mai-Otome is fun but weaker than Mai-Hime. Shigofumi is good as well but it's best parts are in the early episodes for me.

Also, since you made the effort of making an A-P list, the site has an option of comparing your's with other users. Check out mine. I rate most of the stuff I finish so it might also give you some further hints.

You seem to have a healthy amount of mecha, specifically Gundam. So...here's what you're missing:

-Mobile Suit Gundam
-Mobile Suit Gundam F-91
-Mobile Suit Victory Gundam
-Mobile Suit Turn A Gundam
-Mobile Suit Gundam Seed
-Mobile Suit Gundam Seed Destiny
-Mobile Suit Gundam Seed CE73: Stargazer

Here's what I recommend:
-Everything but Gundam Seed and its sequels

For some reason, you haven't seen the first Gundam series. If you don't want to watch the TV version, at least watch the three movies. Also, Gundam F-91 is a movie that was originally meant to be a 50 episode series, so you'll notice they try to pack a lot into it. As for Victory Gundam, it's got even more character deaths than Zeta Gundam. Usually, the rule of thumb is that if a character has a pussy, she's most likely to get killed off. Watch Turn A Gundam after you have seen all the other Gundam series, since it was meant to be the final Gundam series until Seed showed up. Speaking of which, while I hate Gundam Seed, watch Stargazer. It's separate from the main storyline and is only made up of three 15 minute episodes.

Claymore is incomplete, so watch it if you want your day to be filled with extreme awesomeness, only to have it torn down by a bad ending.

Can't go wrong with mecha anime or samurai anime.

well i haven't looked threw all of it but I did see that you haven't seen Mahoromatic or the Nanoha series nano desu and I must suggest you watch those, as well as others, but I'll look around for romance/comedies that you might haven't seen nano desu