Rating Mangas

Sometimes to find a truly wonderful or extraordinary manga you have to search by "most downloaded" or perhaps the "most favorites" but what about a simple 5 star rating system? Only a suggestion. Here is a photoshoped example. (Badly done) I'm sorry if someone else suggested this as well.

One of those pending Ideas which tend to be forgotten:

https://www.fakku.net/viewtopic.php?t=19664&highlight=rating
https://www.fakku.net/viewtopic.php?t=3236&postdays=0&postorder=asc&highlight=rating&start=0

My stand to this Idea has changed pretty much to neutral.
It`s one of those nice features to have, but not essential for the Website.

I like this idea. It works for YouTube, so why not Fakku? :lol:

I don't think it'll work. For the simple fact that everybody likes different styles and different fetishes. For example, there could be a hundred 5-rated anal doujins, but if you're not into it, it's a hundred useless suggestions.

What we do need is the tag system.

yeah. Or a sort by Fetish.

Meh I'm ok with the idea it might be nice to actually be able to do a search specifically for doujins here on Fakku that everyone seems to like alot.

That’s the same thing just with fewer options.

As for a rating its pointless and it never really works. I'll explain ok so there’s a manga with 5 stars and a manga with 3 stars. The 5 star has 3 votes and the 3 star has 5000 votes. Even know more people liked the 3 star it was rated lower. Rating systems like that don't factor in how many people voted.

But then isn't the manga most faved and or downloaded the same thing just more accurate?

Ill agree that most favorites is perhaps the most accurate because only registered user who understand and enjoy the mangas favorite them. So i guess this was a pointless post... Ugh more bad rep from me.