Longevity wrote...
I wanna do the motions for a first person like I wanna walk the guy but also be able to run up to the bad guys and smack them with my gun by swinging my arms or be able to throw the grenade with my own strength not just hold a controler.
I think it's safe to say that people would tire of this quickly. The Wii already has the shortest play time of the three consoles and it's not even all that much work to play Wii games. Also that would still involve some type of controller which as I said defeats Natal's purpose.
doswillrule wrote...
Natal looks like forcing you to be fairly active, and so this, the constraints and the hype they've created by demoing it early and on a big stage might work against them. It is amazing technology, but I doubt the serious gamers who are already somewhat alienated by the Wii's 'hybrid' motion-control are going to dish out for it, and I can't see MS going for the casual demographic.
Natal's E3 Demo kind of failed and the Natal camera's can't even pick up individual finger movement. In my opinion that is not amazing.