hermitVI wrote...
Good timing jmason. I was just about to ask something, perhaps you can enlighten me.
Regarding the series and mostly of what I've seen in the third episode... while I do think that it was great and all (particularly the animation), I can't help it but be baffled with the fact that the girls in this series get romantically attracted with one another so easily, as if it's just a normal thing?
It most likely has got something to do with our culture in viewing lesbians, who casually dresses up and acts like men. The thing is, I don't have the slightest idea of how is it in Japan nor in any other countries. I wonder if it's within the norm there.
Anyway, I have no real problems with coping/dealing with it, knowing that this series is yuri even before I decided to watch it. I just don't get it why it seems like there's nothing unusual to it, judging by most of the characters' reactions. Perhaps I was expecting a little bit too much of realism for my own good.
It's always the case with most of the yuri anime shown. But to answer as to why women get easily attracted to each other in this types of anime, it's due to 3 factors:
1. Lack of men (all-girls schools are always the motifs with these anime)
NOTE: #1 doesn't work on manga much (see Yuri Hime mags)
2. Cultural issues
3. It's how mainstream yuri is
In addressing #2, Japan has a quite lax encapsulation of love boundaries. Lesbians and gays there are more socially accepted (in casual public, yes, but in mainstream public, nope) than in Western countries where there is still a rigid culture of man-and-woman views as a proper relationship. Like if you go to izakayas and late-night parks in Japan, or day/night social areas like Akibahara and Roppongi, you might see one or two lesbians/gays publicly dating. But otherwise from those, it's a private affair.
And lesbians in Japan doesn't have to look like a guy/resemble a bishounen to be real lesbians - they look like average normal women. Maybe they way most people view it differently is because of their own culture. In anime, the main reason some lesbian women resemble a bishonen is that it fills up a niche - the same as the seme-uke relationship in yaoi. In yuri if two women look like the typical Yamato Nadeshiko, it's hard to tell who's the "butch (top)". But if you place one that looks like a bishonen, it's easier to tell by looking. Try Sailor Moon's famed yuri couple. Anyone with a cursory knowledge of yuri can point out who's the "butch" and who's the "femme (bottom)".
'Butch' and 'femme' refer to masculine and feminine women respectively.
But for #3, mainstream yuri, is as you have said it: "the girls in this series get romantically attracted with one another so easily, as if it's just a normal thing". It's how mainstream it is. It's hard to sell it off as yuri if the girls can't easily fall in love with each like that. It's one of the draws and selling points. And they fall in love not because of gender issues but more of personality issues, more like seeing likable qualities in a person. But if you have read some real lesbian light novels and/or less-mainstream lesbian manga, it's not that easy.