K-1 wrote...
I think making it eight episodes was done so they would still have a complete season but not show anything that was going to be in the movie (which I really need to get around to watching).
If they had made five less episodes, they would have only had nine for the season, which would have been a ridiculous number. And in order for them to not include those five episodes but still have fourteen for the season, they would have had to show stuff that would have been in the movie.
Well, regarding the history of haruhi airing,
It doesn't matter which arc is shown actually. Look at the 1st season it's scrambled eggs, yet people still like it anyway. They can just add another story that's not from the movie.
Here's something to add, and it's still in volume 6
-"Snowy Mountain Syndrome"
-"Charmed at First Sight Lover"
-"Where did the Cat Go?"
-"The Melancholy of Mikuru Asahina"
But no, they instead wasted 8 episodes for just one Chapter "Endless Eight". Which they can use half of the episodes to animate those chapters that I mentioned above.
The Rampage of Suzumiya Haruhi (Vol. 5) is filled with Short stories...SHORT.
They just made 8 episodes from just 30 pages of that chapter.
And 2nd season was mostly a recap season
http://chikorita157.com/2009/07/30/the-fiasco-of-suzumiya-haruhi-endless-eight-is-endless/