ImperialX wrote...
Waar wrote...
It's ambiguous for a reason. If we gave specific rules it would allow some users to push and abuse those rules. For example if we had something that said "we allow trolling in IB" there would be no limit in place and some could retreat into the excuse of "the rules don't say I can't" when going overboard. The ambiguity is a way for us to still keep some order mixed in with the chaos.
The rest of Imp's post seems to be complaining about IB, how it's now filled with flaming and trolling. I don't think that has anything to do with the ambiguity of the rules.
But right now according to the rules thread, trolling shouldn't be allowed in IB, except for "special considerations given the nature of the board". I'm just thinking that this "special consideration" is too relaxed, don't you think? I think IB is totally different from the rest of the board, and it seriously should warrant its own set of rules, and naturally "special considerations" so you can keep some order when people start to amuse them.
"Insults, harassment, flaming, trolling, baiting or other similar abusive behavior towards other members of the Forum will not be tolerated." I mean, seriously? Ask any random person who passes by if they think IB obeys these rules including "special considerations", which again, is too ambiguous.
Again, not really complaining. I think the management here is fine, but I do think IB warrants its own set of rules even if it's just for the sake of new users, so they know what to expect.
What? The vagueness of the rules is to allow IB to be that way, it's a place for people to get wild and unload. I think it's serving it's purpose now. It used to be quite a bit like Random but now it's an entirely new board with it's on cultures and sub cultures.
"Insults, harassment, flaming, trolling, baiting or other similar abusive behavior towards other members of the Forum will not be tolerated." doesn't apply in IB, so of course random people will admit no one obeys that list of rules.
While we ensure people don't go overboard I've been told under no uncertain terms that IB should be left to it's own devices. If you want to suggest a warning thread be stickied in IB then make a thread in feedback to discuss it but we aren't adding rules when IB fits the current wishes of the staff.
edit: Locked by OP request.