Let's put this to rest. Tell me a book/movie/etc that had a girl jump down from a jet and start singing J-pop to stop a rebellion or had the main character, who's a renowned terrorist and is trying to take down the world's largest empire, going around wearing an ass-hat, and
the viewers don't care. My point is this - anime excels at bad writing and fans of anime
like anime exactly for its bad writing. See: Code Geass has an 8.70 rating on AniDB. R2 has a temp rating of 8.95. MF has a temp rating of 8.74. What??? If you're arguing that this stuff is genius, then, well... I'm not sure what to say. If a book/movie/etc tried to pull this shit, it'll get shot down by viewers and critics alike in a heart beat.
Plus, you happily ignored my other request: Name an anime this season that you can take seriously. Because I need something else to watch.
ZeroOBK wrote...
I would like to add that the writing in most Romance novels is horrible and makes H-manga and Doujinshi look like they have the best writing in the world. I'm serious this time.
I dunno. I picked up a Daniele Steele novel once and I have to put a tier above horribly placed sex. But a very small tier above.
Tyrenol wrote...
Yeah. Don't you just miss the days when expert writing, plot and character development, and good ol' fashion hard work were prized before any "quickly slapped-together machine" was even considered "fine art?"
This is interesting. You quoted me above this paragraph, but who are you talking to? I never said anything of that sort.
Tyrenol wrote...
And the zombies who'll gladly follow studios like Kyoto Anime, however bad they might treat them, had been spoken for.
KyoAni has fans for a reason. Haruhi was well written enough and I don't see how you can put together a harem anime better than Kanon.