Ultramarinus wrote...
luinthoron wrote...
I present
Exhibit A, Wani's subsequent entry to the western market, before the deal with Fakku. I doubt their plans were just this modest, Fakku just managed to be the first to secure a partnership for the H releases.
And scanlations, including Wani material, are clearly alive and will be in the future. One group disappearing will just be replaced by another. One distribution channel closed will see another rise. It's how it has always been and how it will be in the future, for good or bad.
This might bring us more official English releases, though, especially considering Fakku's magazine simulpublishing plans. Obviously not for free, but no matter how much we love to have free access to all of this, it's really not quite legal and the authors would like to have some money for their work as well.
It could have been so, but then the reason would be another company. In this case, it's Fakku.
It doesn't really work like that as Crunchyroll demonstrated. Many groups died with nobody to replace them. Many groups now merely pick CR script and put it on TV recordings. And that was for anime, here we have hentai, which already limits the potential amount of contributors. It won't be how it has always been. Threat of legal pursuit will marginalize the output of the scene.
Overall, I'm not sure that'll be the case as there'll be many works that's going to be considered as 'unsuitable for western audiences'. Not to mention that some authors would be less preferred just based on sales figures. I'd happy to be wrong, of course but I doubt it as we already have many previous samples of what gets officially translated and what isn't on Fakku store.
Blaming Fakku for bringing you content that would otherwise just have disappeared isn't really helping anyone.
Crunchytroll caused a small break in fansubbing for about two seasons, after which many groups already started ignoring their (at least at that time) substandard translations and doing their own again. Some have died, yes, but that has always been happening as people move on to other pursuits or have less time due to RL commitments. I'm barely active myself these days, and certainly not due to Crunchytroll. Admittedly, I'm not happy with the simple use of CR scripts these days, though. Manga is much easier to work with than anime, though, so contributors will be much easier to find than for anime releases. Whether it is actually necessary, is debatable. We'll see once we see how this business goes.
As for "unsuitable", Jacob has already confirmed publishing loli, there's not much that would be more controversial these days. I guess the full extent of releases remains to be seen, but he has clearly shown interest in publishing as much as possible.