Gubi wrote...
I understand the breaking the forums part, and that's pretty reasonable. It is true that huge threads kinda wreck havock.
But why make it a tradition if it contents none other than yourself? Is this the traditional ritual of giving a virgin to the dragon so he leaves the village alone? There are plenty of threads that grow upwards of a thousand pages, some double of that, but they aren't closed.
It did wreak havoc before, threads used to break when they got that long, but that was only a problem for a short time, it has nothing to do with the Fakku of today.
The next question doesn't make sense, doing something because I enjoy it is the only reason I need, regardless of how few others it "contents".
Gubi wrote...
Reminding people that the place is a gift is certainly a valid point, we are after all using a free forum for which we pay nothing (although there are ads in the reading part of the site, but I digress). So truly we are grateful, we like the site, we like the forum, that is why we are active here. So why close a thread arbitrarily? What could we have done that sends the message that we do not care for the site or that we feel entitled to something more than cordial relationships and correct service?
You are grateful, as long as mods are there to help whenever you need/want them, you feel that everything is being run as you believe it should be run and as long as nothing upsets your world(none of this is exclusively you). Anything outside of your expectations is met with resistance, hostility, and a general tone of disrespect(again not specifically you).
Why close the thread? As I said, fun and a reminder that nothing is a right. I dont know why you're trying to get another reason out of me, does fun not make sense?
Gubi wrote...
Sure we moan about the maintenance and we moan about the bugs, but when something is fixed we laud it and when an iniatitive is good we support it. Why would you feel a need to remind people that the forums are gift? More precisely, why the café? Or do you regularly close other threads with the same objective in mind?
You witness a fraction of the complaining; a small percentage of posts in feedback, the amount of emails and pm's the staff get a day(mostly Jake) would truly shock you. In comparison, amount of praise we get doesn't amount to much and often get drowned out by all the white noise of complaints. We dont even mind, it's our "job"(very few of us get paid) and we signed up for it. So from time to time when someone acts as if it's their God given right to post anything they want, or to double and triple post the staff feels the need to remind them that it's not. The cafe was simply the worst offenders for the longest time, and to some extent they still are.
Gubi wrote...
We don't want special treatment. If you want to instore a thread page limit, its easily doable and enforceable, and people will mostly be ok with it, so long as it's to protect the intergrity of the forums and facilitate usage.
Sorry long post but I wanted to try and convey my point of view on the situation. Could I have your own, if you've got the time?
Edit: Also why is it fun? Do mods have a secret kink for closing threads? XD
No special treatment? The idea that no users except a "cafe" regular should start one of these threads isn't special? To be fair I would say that's very special treatment. I don't even mind letting that go on, but don't for a second think you don't ask for privilege.
See that's where I lose you, "and people will mostly be ok with it,
so long as". This forum isnt a democracy, you have no right to make demands or have expectations, anytime we take your advice or do something you want it's a gift, a reward, the staff trying to make this place more fun, but it's not your right. If I wanted to ban the use of the word "the", force everyone to post in green and limit the letter "k" from peoples names all I would need is support from one man and
there is nothing anyone could do. Obviously we wont do any of that, because it's stupid and there's no point, but if I choose to lock one thread when it nears 10000 posts because it's fun then that's what will happen.
Not sure I can explain why it's fun, I just do(posts like these help).