krakis wrote...
Here's my first attempt at typesetting. I'd love any and all criticism for how I can improve. I decided to try my hand at Caged Bird.
I tried to level it but I'm not sure if I made it too dark.
The only problems I had were:
I didn't know how to replace the title in english.
I didn't replace the 2 characters at the bottom left because the only way I thought would work would be a text box but I wasn't sure if that was a good idea since it would be over his face.
http://www.imagebam.com/image/97f0ed345964851
Ah, Arai Kei is a tricky one for levelling.
The pages have actually already been levelled. If you look at the title block on that page, you'll see that the blacks are really already black before you've even touched it.
I own a few Arai Kei books in real life, and they all have that washed out shade of grey, like they've been done in pencil. It's what they're supposed to look like, but it's hard to know that unless you've seen one before. ;)
Don't worry about the title if you're not confident doing it. It would be a major job to make it look right, and I'm not even that sure how I'd go about starting that one. Myself, I'd probably just avoid it altogether on the basis that I'd likely only make it look worse. As it is at least it's pretty, and people can get the title from the file name.
Likewise the bit over his face. It's only a sigh, and if you're not sure you can do it cleanly you're better off leaving the original text in place. It's not a big deal.
However, you should be aware that later on in the book there is text that is part of the story (and thus needs to be placed) that is not in a bubble. Pages 18, 22, 26, 27, 28, and 32. These parts will need the text to be placed and then the art behind them redrawn. None of them are horrendously difficult as far as redraws go, but neither are they particularly easy. If you haven't done redraws before you may find it very difficult.
If you want to continue, I'd go and have a look at those parts first (and double check the other pages to see that I haven't missed any more). Those are going to be the hardest sections, so I'd do those first so that you don't get stuck halfway through. I've seen it happen to people before, and my redraw skill isn't really good enough to help you out if you get stuck, unfortunately. :( I get a bit lost after anything that's more complicated than content aware clone can handle. ;)