OFFICIAL MIDORI NO RUUPE THREAD

M*TH*FU*K*N DOUCHEBAGS!!!! AAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHGGGGGGGGGGGGGG! RAGE! I AM PISSED OFF! Why the hell did this awesome oneshot gone to this direction!!!

Excuse me for the rage guys, just that I am really pissed off! Hey good job author/circle for making this NTR really spread rage to all of us (frikin sarcasm to the max!). I for one who started admiring the series at first, after all Cat Head Imako was cute and funny, and we can feel the love. And now WHAT?!

First of all guys, please tell me that the Imako-san to Yakubutsu Gaku I and II AND Imako-san to Kimodameshi IS IN A DIFFERENT FRIKIN UNIVERSE from Cat Head Imako?! Cuz if it is the same story then call me a noob cuz things just dont make sense to me!

First of all in Cat Head Imako they (Ichina and Imako) were just friends right? Then all of a sudden here in Imako-san to Neko Kaburi they are step siblings what the hell? It doesnt make sense. Then in Imako-san to Ichina-kun I they are considered as lovers??? First of all Imako's virginity was taken in Cat Head Imako, then she's a virgin again in Imako-san to Neko Kaburi and Imako-san to Ichina-kun??? What about in Imako-san to Yakubutsu Gaku I, it said she was a virgin again (although I know from the credits of the scanlator saying it could be the effect of the drugs), but why the hell did Ichina mention it then? when he WASNT affected by the drugs and only Imako? Also in Imako-san to Yakubutsu Gaku II it was mentioned once again that she was a virgin? WTH IS GOING ON? I'm really seriously mind fucked!

Now we get the RAGE series of Imako-san to Yakubutsu Gaku I and II AND Imako-san to Kimodameshi!

GUYS BIG SPOILER, IF YOU DONT WANT TO READ ANYMORE NTR, DAM EVEN MnR's latest work has made me rage even further! So Please dont flame me for this, you have been warned. Reading the unscanlated Imako-san to Kimodameshi:

Oh man I dont know guys, this is MnR's latest work, and from what I can see, he's going to continue the NTR and would probably end badly like ALL NTRs! RAGE! Why do I say all NTRs end badly? Cuz all the NTRs I read have bad endings, (I know right?! I hate myself most of all for reading continuing to read NTR HOPING that it will END GOOD THE WAY I WANT IT). So what is my definition of a good ending for an NTR? Hell since NTR we all know that the main guy's girlfriend's is already leftovers, already wasted garbage after enjoying all the things done to her that she doesnt give a dam anymore.

So what kind of ending do I want for an NTR? I dont want the main guy to just rescue the girl, because this happens way too late in ALL NTR and by then the girl is already used to cheating IF not the guy at most only ends up beating the bad guy, and ultimately, the bad guy gets away with it. He lives and has the possibility to do it again...

So wouldn't NTR be much more better to read after we all rage and felt a satisfying ending in the end? I want the main guy to rescue the main girl by either killing the bad guy (the good end) or having the bad guys' dicks cut off and let them rot in jail for life to be raped constantly by cons who have that interest (let them have a taste of their own wrongdoings), that's the best end for a series IMO (how about you guys? Can you think of the best way to deal punishment for these NTR bastards?)

As for the girl it depends... First of all if the girl can recover either by forgetting all about it OR regrets it so much that she wont ever do it again after realizing that she loves the main guy too much then the Main guy should take her back and be with her even though for the main guy this must take one hell of guts for you to continue having a relationship with a girl knowing what she's done to you (IMO I wouldn't continue such a relationship or I will seriously go insane that will make yandere pale in comparison). BUT This is really a rare event in NTR (I think i've only seen like 2 series who has this kind of ending). OR THE BEST in my opinion is just for the main guy to leave the main girl by going out with another girl that this time he will make sure not to make the dam stupid mistakes he made in the beginning and to love his new found love and to never let her go, AND at the same time make his old girl REGRET IT ALL (I always felt like this after watching the Blue series videos like Triangle Blue and True Blue).

Though I get that the main girl isn't the only one at fault her and partly (or mostly? by some other's opinion) that it is the main guy's fault for this ending. In this series? It could largely be Ichina's dam curiosity to use the drug on Imako so I was insanely pissed when Ichina had done it. BUT is it entirely his fault then? I read the series carefully and I would say no, not at all. It was an honest human error and that he was curious in using it BECAUSE of only the fact that his girlfriend was reading books about drugs that can ruin their life. He was concerned and wondered what kind of drug it is. If you guys NOTICED CAREFULLY, in the Imako-san to Yakubutsu Gaku II, Imako already knows about IT!!!, she blamed that bastard guy who gave Ichina the drugs and wondered why he did it!!! PLUS SHE WAS CARRYING THE BOOK WITH HER MOST OF THE TIME TO USE IT AS A MEANS TO TRANSPORT THE DRUGS!!! In Imako-san to Yakubutsu Gaku II it is revealed that she's using it to masturbate. SO WHO IS THE ONE WHO HAD THE ULTIMATE FAULT? The main guy and girl are at fault for falling victims, BUT ULTIMATELY it is the NTR bastard! Which is why the only way MnR can satisfy me is he would give ONE HELL OF A GRUESOME ENDING FOR THAT NTR BASTARD!!!

<SIGHS> Man I haven't rage this much since I last saw Triangle Blue, why the hell do I bother reading or watching NTR with a hope that it will actually have a decent ending??? Man I hate myself for that! I frikin hate NTR with a passion (but at least I tend to not have that much rage to series that I know already starts off as NTR), but when I see a good series that turns into an NTR like IMAKO, it is just a whole 'nother (Mad TV style) LEVEL OF RAGE!!!!


Sorry for the long post, I just had to let out some steam! I mean you guys must have felt the same way like me who was initially excited to hear that there was a sequel to Cat Head Imako to only end up like this! I just felt a RAGE I never felt in my entire life man, it's like after all that excitement of learning an awesome sequel to just turn like this plus the fact that i think it's going to continue like this down the road in the future just makes me feel so much mix of emotions from rage, disappointment, sadness perhaps, and whole lots of things. I saw some of MnR's series and it was really good, so why the hell did he do this? He better give us a dam good ending we could all at least live with lol.

(I apologize if its wrong to swear here, I will edit the post later if you find it offensive guys just tell me)

Your completely right man, I just read the english version of Imako-san to Yakubutsu Gaku II and tried understanding -Imako-san to Kimodameshi, and I can just say Imako is a lost cause. Poor Ichina after The worst part about it is we can all sympathize with Ichina because it is normal to feel jealousy and doubt of his girlfriend when he saw Imako walking together with another guy and having lively conversations that she used to have with him.

I mean I think Imako is truly a lost case now, because we can all say that Imako is doing this because of the drugs so she is forced to do those things for that guy, BUT what about afterwards? When the drug wears off? Why the hell is Imako still so okay and even a lot closer to that NTR bastard? She even spends most of her time with him than Ichina and worst part about it all! She doesnt even feel a tiny bit of regret about her actions, hell I dont even think she cares or worries about Ichina anymore and just cares about the drugs and just doing it with anyone.

Sad that this series went to this direction, and your completely right lol! It is not ultimately the character's fault but the author for having a screwed up imagination of thinking of mind fukin his popular one shot series into this.

I dont completely hate NTR authors because I know that some people love this genre, and I dont hate them for having that interest as well, hell even I admit that I am drawn towards NTR rage lol and curiosity of whether or not the ending will satisfy me and would be unique towards the NTR genre. All the NTR series I either read or watch so far, I already knew will end up in NTR because the series genre is NTR or have a cheating girlfriend/wife tag on it. So at least we know what this series is about and we cant completely rage on it, cuz we can all say, hey you know its an NTR, so why the hell would you still continue reading or watching it then? That's fine, but this series is COMPLETELY DIFFERENT! I mean it started out so awesome and for some messed screwed reason the author just decided to drop a bomb on us! Why ruin such an amazing series? This is why my NTR rage for this series is completely different from all NTR series I have read so far.

When i first saw the cat-head imako I was actually sort of "touched", by the sentimentality in a porn comic. If it wasn't for my friends forwarding me weird shit I probably would not have come across this great and now terrible creation. It really bugs me how this happens, but I do have a question if someone in this thread could please answer:

I always have held out in life in general for a "brighter side"...
Now while it seems apparent that Imako is turning into the classic NTR slave. And we see this all but diminished in the beginning of Kimodameshi where as it introduces the childhood romance, she is plowed by the sick manipulator himself. And it really filled me with a sense of dread to now see she will be used as a cum dump most likely. However I am a novice when it comes to things like interpreting, or translating, or just knowing if such answers have already been stated. I only originally got into doujins when a friend sent me Re-Take; which I thought was awesome because I'm a NGE freak. Anyway to my main point: on the last page of the Kimodameshi on the bottom portion we see Mimi's grave and something is being thought or said. What is being thought or said? or what was implied if someone could humor me?

My friend says there are the occasional doujins which go NTR, but end well. The only one he mentioned was really long. Plot was basically two friends who were always together since childhood are now in highschool. And of course the male character is oblivious to the girl liking him, but i aware of his feelings for her. Anyway the basis of the plot is after the girl reveals to him that the captain of the football team or something asks her out she asks if it's okay (something that is emotionally significant, but not revealed until later). Anyway you all know the drill then. The "captain" makes her into a cum bucket, eventually letting the school team ravage her, and then forcing one of the good guy's friends to do her. In the end however the good guy has a moment of clarity, they go kick the football team's ass and save her. And the last chapter is them bumping uglies, but in a reconciliation sort of way that tries to redeem the meaningfulness that was lost in the first chapter. The name escapes me at the time, I will ask him later if he can re-forward it to me.

My point is this is eerily similar to that. However, this is also eerily similar to the 5 ntr's I know of, in which such "strong bonds" are simply nothing compared to sexual ecstasy. So i'm hoping on two things: One being the character will eventually save the girl through a moment of clarity for himself, and 2: by the time he comes to help she is not a lost cause. Because one has happened before, but if one does happen usually 2 does not.

So to re clarify, and to apologies; Can someone tell me what the significance is at the end of Kimodameshi with the cat grave and what not? Is it something hopeful? And I'm sorry for the walls of texts. This is my first, and probably one of the few times I will ever post. But this comic is simply to engaging to just ignore and try to forget.

Yes I know the usual characteristics of girls in NTR series and about the story you mentioned, well I havent read it, I just googled and saw that it is actually labeled already as cheating wife genre so it's no surprised that it is NTR. Cat Head Imako had no indication at all whatsoever for it.

That's why thanks a lot, deftera_mirage! For clearing that up! Because people's replies in this thread make it seem like all of the different stories somehow link together as one from cat head imako (even I can see the connection BUT not without SO MUCH CONFUSION AND CONTRADICTIONS PERHAPS EVEN PARADOXES OF IT LOL). So I'm somewhat relieved that it isn't connected, even though you're right that it is still related because they use the exact same characters with the same names just different roles and one disgusting story. But the reason why I hate myself for doing so, is I'll know that I would continue reading on just to satisfy my curiosity in knowing what the ending or conclusion will be. I know that I will regret it, just as all NTR series I've read and watched, I have always regretted the end. That's why I'm always searching for a unique NTR series that will have a unique original ending, like my ideal good or best endings I mentioned in my previous post lol.



If you can see my post in the previous page (page 3) I even posted a lot longer post than you lol, so dont worry about it. Believe me, I understand how you feel about this series, and you share the exact same sentiments as I do about the guy rescuing the girl and hoping it's not a lost cause (because the girl realizes that she loves the guy more than anything) BUT I dont think it's gonna happen at all in this series.

I mentioned this as well in my previous other post, that it is now a lost cause to hope that Imako will change and regret it all. WHY? Look at Imako-san to Yakubutsu Gaku II properly as well as that dam latest NTR Imako-san to Kimodameshi, IMAKO HAS NOT SHOWN ONE OUNCE OF REGRET TOWARDS ICHINA! Hell I know she was drugged and forced to have sex, BUT afterwards when the drugs' effects are gone WHY IS SHE STILL TALKING LIVELY TO THE NTR GUY AND EVEN GOTTEN CLOSER TO HIM THAN ICHINA! Believe me man, I am an amateur in translating, but what I can tell from the last page of Mii's grave is some sort of FORESHADOWING more than anything, I believe that just as Mii who Ichina really cares about was separated to him, it will be the same as Imako. I can already tell or predict the ending to this shitty story and the part I hate about myself is still wanting to see it through the end (despite the raging heartache) with the hope that it's not a lost cause, by either Imako regretting it and going back to Ichina and Ichina rescuing her by beating up the guys (GOOD END, NOT MY DEFINITION OF BEST END).

My IDEAL BEST ENDING for this NTR Series is to have Ichina finally open his eyes and see what kind of person Imako is now, and knowing this is the fault of BOTH Imako and the NTR Drug Bastard, is to have Ichina first rescue Imako by beating up the NTR Drug bastard and BEAT all his friends senseless and cutting or hacking off their dicks, then have them all arrested for life (by making the charges a lot serious that could garner them life in prison without parole), and while in prison pay off a bunch of cons to rape them senseless for life. That's the best punishment for those bastards.

The BEST Punishment for Imako is to have her realize that all she's done is wrong and have her regret it, simply by moving on and dating a different girl and from learning all his mistakes from Imako, to keep his new girl close to him, with no major secrets (unlike Imako who was secretly using drugs), and to actually love her to go in a long term serious relationship that is not just based on lust. Break up with Imako of course and have her realize how foolish her actions was, by showing that Ichina finally moved on and has now know about truly loving someone. Thus show this in front of Imako and have her regret it for the rest of her life. Happy ending for the guy who doesnt deserve this (you are completely right, deftera_mirage), because the guy has done something stupid with his curiosity BUT even had he not done it, Imako will eventually end up like that since she kept using the drugs to masturbate. So have her regret it all for the rest of her life, have the ntr bastards without dicks now and getting screwed senseless by cons in prison for life, and have Ichina moved on with a different girl happily ever after. (Hell even if he received a happy ending with a new girl, that would still be quite a huge scar that he has to carry, but at the very least have Ichina a proper closure he deserves) That is one HAPPY ENDING!

Which is assumed however. With the style NTR's follow, or seem to follow, the cat that meant a great breaking point int heir relationship in the alternate reality, might be his foreshadowing nightmare in this one. Which would be a damn shame. But that is why I want a close/exact translation. Because this style of story telling can quickly change its mood, and so I believe, the most recent chapter and the next will undoubtedly say it all. If there is anything left to say however... You have to keep the readers reading don't you?

My friend says this is turning into a sanbun kyoden comic. I have yet to see one of these, but apparently they all are like this... Oh well. It took about a month more or less to come from the alternate universe comic, so hopefully within a month or less the answer will be fully apparent.

I'm sorry I'm new... I totally forgot I should of put spoilers around my first posting... Sorry><. However I do not want this to be a rage thread. It does suck majorly that bad things are occurring, will seem to continue to occur, and maybe won't ever get better buttttttt, the only reason why I actually am posting in this is because of the original Cat-head doujin.

So I will to my better lack of judgment follow this. I really do want to know what happens on that last page, because honestly there can't be much left if purely ntr? You can keep pushing more ntr themes I guess, but unless there is a string of hope, it already hit rock bottom I might say. So I could only assume two more issues: One to hit the nail in the good guy's head, and the second being the wrap up. So I would appreciate those who are willing to share and help me understand Midori's ((now infamous) series Imako.

I just read "Imako-san to Ichina-kun I" and "Imako-san to Yakubutsu Gaku I" the other day and something about those 2 doujins just seemed different from "Cat-head Imako" somehow, though I can't really say what it is. Maybe it's the story, but I'm not saying there's anything wrong with it, it's just that it gave a sort of feeling that something is gonna go wrong sooner or later...

This series, so far, has made me depressed as hell.

I don't get authors like this, why do you start with something sweet, happy, and GOOD and then just have it starting to spiral downward! Listen I can take a step down into a darker plot, but please, if your going to start it cutesy, don't bring the story down into the pitch black Sub-basement!

It's like, Golden Boy. "Hey this series is cool! Guy that wants to learn everything, trying to get some action, not good at it, but the girls fall for him when its to late and he's gone!" Then I get to the friggin rich a-hole that has been brainwashing women and men to worship him as a god, ruining a couple that had been together for years, and basically had the main hero loose completely, but accept it! "... ... WTF!!!" If I wanted to read a manga that makes me disgusted and depressed I would read Franken Fran!

Im not saying that all manga's have to be light and fluffy. Listen, I'm fine with a H-manga series that has a downer period. Take on Me series had a down period. Tayu Tayu has its down periods too! I would have loved if this series was dealing with drug abuse and such, and how it can ruin a couple. It would be melancholy but I would have been okay with it.

My hope is that series can have a silver lining. Have the guy realize whats going on and try to save his sister through marriage and bring them back together!

My last thought is what I wish would happen one time, or wish I could know about one that happened. A Subverted NTR. Where the male lead is forced to watch his love interest get boned by another guy, but instead of loosing all hope, goes into a rage like Scrooge McDuck int the Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck Series.


Part 1
Part 2
Part 3

Yeah if that would happen in a faux NTR, I would be in total freak-out-total-win mode.

Well it is slightly obvious that they could not be the same. Of course it is the author's work and they can make them connect somehow, or in a quote somewhere they can say "same girl, same universe", but without either the evidence is pretty conclusive. I just wished it helped.

I tried going to Midori's website as well, I cannot read the stuff, but I have a few translators. However, whatever he is writing my crappy translators don't like... however the author has made a few comment's about imako, but I cannot tell if they are good or bad. However, if people are hoping for the 5th comic to start looking happy, well you can visit his website. In the upper right hand corner he has two pages as a preview I am supposing, and neither look very flattering for Imako, or the comic's trend.

I'm hoping by the end of the 5th, or the 6th for that matter; the fate of the series will be permanently decided. Here's to hoping~