I used to do my fair share of paragraph role playing in Yahoo! Chat user rooms (when they still existed - dates me back a bit), and from what I remember, proper grammar was simply a status symbol and a way of getting others to "stfu." It somehow marked "elite" players from "inferior" players, and helped the "elite" win many a pointless chat room argument EVEN THOUGH many "inferior" players were much more prolific, creative (even in a literary sense), and less flowery in their story-telling, or RIGHT in some of the chat room arguments. I love English, so I don't mind when someone flexes their grammar elbow or rubs on that Oxford comma too hard, but all this grammar nazism that some people lord over others, especially when they were able to get a point across just fine, is unnecessary.
Plus, when I get lazy or I'm fapping or some shit, I don't want some fuckin' asshat trolling a hentai forum of all places to correct my faulty grammar.
edit:
ShaggyJebus wrote...
A lot of famous writers have essentially given the middle finger to grammar in their writings. William Faulkner, for example, used a ton of "improper" sentences; he could make one sentence last for pages, thanks to a lot of commas and semicolons and such. Of course, he always had a reason for doing so, but it makes you think. If the best writers can flagrantly toss grammar aside while writing masterpieces, then why should we worry about everything looking neat and prim and proper when we write something? At least, that's what I always thought in my writing classes, when my teacher told me that I couldn't have my characters use improper English or that I couldn't use sentence fragments.
Just felt like throwing that out there.
Well, er... they did it for the sake of art or to convey something. Artful rule-breaking expresses intentionality, is functional, "makes you think," as you said. We're not writing masterpieces when we're posting on a forum. I'm merely pointing out the difference between intentional rule breaking and unintentional rule breaking, but honestly, I don't care when "sum1 types liek tihs."