These pretty much summed up the first part of what I wanted to say, so I won't repeat what others already covered.
fatman wrote...
GoldenBuoy wrote...
Oh boy. Respect should be earned, as in you have to teach people how they should treat you. Hmm.
Why should respect be earned? It should be given be default, then taken away if the person is an ass.
Can't you see it? The inherent contradiction of that stance? Earning YOUR respect would imply you are some hotshot person whose opinion matters. But then who the fuck are you? Why should anyone respect you? Have you earned any respect at all? Can you imagine people treating you with the level of respect you have earned, which is none at all?
This is why so many kids are fucking assholes. They go around running "Yo! You have to earn my respect, bitch!"
I was taught at a young age to treat others the way I want to be treated but to respect my elders. What if those elders are not in any place to be given respect due to there actions? Like for instance, A former Nazi who was responsible for millions of innocent people's deaths? Should they be given respect for the horrible things they've done?
Yes. There is still a modicum level of respect to such a person, if only to show you are a better person. It is not their age that you are giving respect to, but to society itself.
To put it another way:
The Nazis were willing to slaughter jews because they saw them as animals.
Now, if you treat the Nazi as an animal, what does that make you? That just makes you the winner of the war, but not his better. He wold have done the exact same thing to you had his side won.
When you treat the nazi war criminal with respect, you are saying to the world "I am better than this maggot."
What he said. I think you should respect everybody, and that it should be lost, not earned.
Quoted for truth.
I suppose my next step would be to say that in addition to having a certain level of respect for everyone be default, I feel that more people should be more understanding of a situation before assuming that said person is no longer worthy of respect. Back home in Nippon, there are many kinds of people - understanding people, indifferent people, observant people - and then there are others who will see part of a situation and make conclusions on their own that may or may not be correct.
Basically, for example, when my elder brother helped me shop for clothing one time, he was accused of being a pervert even though he didn't touch anything or anyone, or do anything wrong, just for accompanying me to the story, because I was still a child and was a lot younger than him.
But he was just doing our mother a favor, so that I had clothes for everyday, and we also planned to pick up groceries at the supermarket on the way home for dinner. We had all that trouble because someone assumed that my brother was a 'lolicon', which is basically calling him a pedophile, just because he carried my clothes to the counter.
Of course, my brother was excused once they found out the truth, but we didn't get to eat dinner until almost 21:30, because the security guards kept him there until our father got off work and could come by to pick us up.
Basically, what I'm saying is, everyone should always hold their assumptions to a situation before trying to exercise false justice. I feel like that's probably society's response to a population that is writhe with more and more perverts, but the way we treat these people isn't going to make them better - it's only going to make them worse.
For example - if I were raped, I wouldn't trust our justice system to correct them - because in Nippon it seems like every sex-related crime committed ends up becoming worse if the same person commits it again after imprisonment. Basically, we're treating these people like animals, and that is exactly what we're turning them into.
At that point, while it is partly their fault for committing the initial crime, the fault also lies with out system that makes their lives a living hell, treats them like garbage, and then tosses them onto the street to be treated even worse.
As a victim of attempted rape, I wanted the man attacking me to stop, but at the same time, I was afraid to call the police, not because they would imprison him, but because of what they would do to him in prison, make him worse, and then spit him out into the world as a person with only hatred and grudges.
I guess, the highlight of all of this is - People need to treat people better, even if they do bad things, because if we do bad things to others after they commit crimes, then are we really any better? Are we less like animals? Are we worth more than garbage? I wouldn't think so. I would think the people that would guide criminals in the right direction and give them a second chance, those are the people to be admired, those are the people who SHOULD be given the power.
Sorry for so much text, I just couldn't make it short and simple... will work on that.