gizgal wrote...
cruz737 wrote...
gizgal wrote...
It's one thing to be honest. it's another to oogle someone and/or take and post photographs of unknowing/unwilling persons online for others to jack off to.
It is fine to have desires, but expressing them at the cost of others' personal comfort, safety, and dignity is plain creepy and horrid.
This statement coming from a person who shares okaycupidgoldmine pics for a good ole laugh...(pretty much a public shaming site for weirdos or just generally people you find distasteful on okay cupid the dating site, most if not all of the time, the information is taken without their consent)
Hypocrisy.
But you know what, but of this things should be legally fine(well not always legal depending on where you live and who you're photographing), even if the price is personal discomfort.
Those people shared their own images publicly, on a site where people judge each other constantly. That's one thing. Not at great thing to share them, sure, but most images that make it to those blogs at least have some identifying info removed or omitted to keep said person anonymous besides their image.
What the issue is, is to be taking photos of others without their consent.
I agree, even I make fun of people sometimes. But not the the extent of endangering their personal safety through revealing sensitive personal information, whereabouts, or identity, with intent to harm.
The laws considering, how, where and who you can film/photograph is tricky, and ripe for abuse(In Illinois and man is facing up to 70 years of jail time for video taping a police officer, without the officers consent). I think if you're going to to make this issue about personal discomfort(not dangerous in itself) and that harm might come from it(hardly if not ever true, and not worth the price of freedom imo) we're going down the slippery slope argument, one in which I can easily make a scenario like "what if someone who saw this someone in this site whose opinion they though was unacceptable and they should be punished". It's not hard to know where, when images were taken, or the profile of any individual on that site.
You said it's about taking photos, but why should personal/individual feelings stop there? The people who went to these sites never intentioned for them to be on the okcgoldmine site, and I'm guessing there a few who felt hurt/humiliated/harmed, but you know what? That's okay.
FYI
I don't think the DMCA claim was justifiable when they took down the site, nor do I find the site objectionable.