I would personally go with the
Qanba Q1 [PS3 X PC]. What you have posted I would only suggest if you are only playing by yourself or just have a very small interest in playing fighting games [or the occasional STG] and trying to decide if getting into it feels right. That hori is , by the books, a trial controller.
If that is not the case with you, then just get the Qanba Q1. It's cheap enough that it wouldn't be too much of a investment, but good enough to where it doesn't feel lacking if by chance you hunger for something more.