I played: You, Tsugumi, Sora, Sara, Youknowwho
I think Sara's route gives away too much of the story so you're better off playing it just before the last route, just to maintain suspense or whatever.
I'm ashamed to say that kick the can wasn't the only bit that freaked me out. All the stuff related to
near the start of the game really freaked me out especially when
you try to drown yourself near the start
It's not even like I scare easily, I really enjoy my horror movies but this game still gave me the chills.
Also, am I the only who
cried like a bitch at the end of Sora's arc? Twice.