Fakku Top 10 v2.0

amorim · 2012-07-01T19:19:40+00:00

Well, let's bring some news. We're thinking of making a revision to the current Fakku Recommends thread and for that, it was also decided to make a new Fakku Top 10. However, this thread will be more strict about your list because your list will probably be considered to the new Fakku Recommends. For that reason, please be advised that if your post does not meet the required criteria, it won't be considered. Also, the main pic is the same as the other thread because it's a crime to change it so please don't mind it. With this said, here are the conditions: Given that we're a english community, please post translated Visual Novels only. You can post untranslated ones but you have at least to post your translated list. It's preferable for you to have at least 10 Visual Novels played. The Visual Novels world is pretty big and there are a lot of masterpieces out there. Preferebly post 10 Visual Novels but 5 are enough. If you don't classify your list, your post won't be considered. The same if you don't post at least 5 Visual Novels. I'll eventually post to keep track of the votes. Let's call it a "reminder to myself". If you change your list. you can post again if I already posted my "reminder" also saying that you already posted previously. If I didn't post the "reminder", edit your previous post. Finally, here is my list: 1 - Muv Luv Alternative 2 - Clannad 3 - Ever17 -the out of infinity- 4 - Higurashi 5 - Umineko 6 - Little Busters! 7 - Tsukihime 8 - Fate/stay night 9 - ef - a fairy tale of the two. 10 - Cross† Channel

Pages 123

Zolnir

12 years ago

Well I assume we're just going to compile a list of Top 10, and list those extra VNs under the same category or special mentions just like before.

Kaimax Best Master-San

12 years ago

And this is just a collection of Opinions in fakku, there are already many sites that specifically list like this. we don't need to try and rival those sites.

The point of this list, is what VN is the most "liked" in fakku that's it.

[b]Last unrelated post. Do not try to create more argument/discussion[b]

igantio

12 years ago

here is igantio's list of eroge

English FanTranslated eroge
1. edelwiess phantasia
2. demon bane
3. bazooka cafe
4. edelwiess
5. fate stay night
6. kirakira
7. virgin rooster
8. rewrite
9. kamidori alchemy meister
10. baldr sky dive x

i'm a newbie so forgive the crude mix off titles/ genres

Ryssen

12 years ago

1. Fate// Stay Night
2. Katawa Shoujo
3. The Drug That Makes You Dream

I've only played these three..... yet. Starting Majikoi and School Days, but since I'm not even done with one route I can't say much.

So I should, like, download these suggestions, right?

Sanada-Kun

12 years ago

[color=red]Well, since I'm in mood for some VN now, I'm gonna make my list

1. G-Senjou no Maou
2. Daibanchou Big Bang Age
3. Majikoi (partially translated)
4. To Heart 2 (partially translated)
5. Lovely x Cation (full jap)
6. Sengoku Rance
7. A drugs that makes you dream
8. Utawarerumono
9. Bishoujo Mangekyou (the first story, and full jap)
10. Katawa Shoujo

As you can see, I prefer light/comedic stories one. Rarely played "serious" VN, but I might try one soon.

Lelouch24

12 years ago

[color=#2e1a6b]I've only played these 5, which I like in this order:

1. Fate/stay night
2. G-senjou no Maou
...
3. Sharin no Kuni
4. Katawa Shoujo
5. Ever 17

CakeSamurai

12 years ago

Just my personal top 10 and I see so far you guys have pretty great tastes! Good lists :)

1. Ever17
2. Sharin no Kuni - Himawari and Yuukyuu (not sure if allowed :P)
3. Muv Luv Alternative
4. Majikoi
5. Steins;Gate
6. Kara no Shoujo
7. G-Senjou
8. Kira Kira
9. Utawarerumono
10. DearDrops

Graceland

12 years ago

(The amount of VN's I've completed so far is kinda limited - Only played 14 so far; Currently trying to get 100% CG in Kamidori; I'm at around 84% +- ... So I'll go with the ones I have tried)

1. Kamidori Alchemist Meister
2. CLANNAD
3. Kira Kira
4. DEARDROPS
5. Koihime Musou
6. Little Busters!
7. Yume Miru Kusuri
8. Edelweiss
9. Princess Waltz
10. Dengeki Stryker

I've got a question; Aoishiro - Is it a good game? Is it worth the playtime?
I havn't actually gotten started on it or anything, hence why I'm asking for peoples thoughts, though I'm considering going for it :) So... What are your thoughts?

bad3ip420

12 years ago

All are English Translated

1. Ever 17 -out of infinity-
2. G-Senjou no Maou
3. Tsukihime
4. Sharin no kuni, himawari shoujo
5. Crescendo
6. Saya no uta
7. Remember 11
8. Figures of Happiness
9. One -to the radiant season-
10. Chaos Head

Noutakun

12 years ago

Still only going to do a top 5.

1. Muv Luv Alternative
2. Little Busters
3. G-senjou no Maou
4. Ever17 -Out of Infinity-
5. Fate/stay-night

shinsan

12 years ago

1. Muv-Luv Alternative
2. Little Busters
3. Fate/Stay Night
4. Clannad
5. G-Senjou no Maou
6. Cross Channel
7. Sengoku Rance
8. ef - a fairy tale of the two
9. Maji de Watashi ni Koishinasai
10. Tsukihime (A remake would probably put it ahead of FSN)

Hard for me to compare older classics to newer games. I would say Clannad heroines (Yukine, Tomoyo, Kyou, Kotomi) are probably the most memorable, but I liked the themes in Little Busters more. Similarly with Tsukihime, but I think newer readers will be more amenable to the more polished graphics and interface of Fate.

Sir Fapselot

12 years ago

1. Muv-Luv Alternative
2. Clannad
3. Ever17 -the out of infinity-
4. Cross† Channel
5. Fate/Stay Night
6. G-Senjou no Maou
7. Tsukihime
8. Hoshizora no Memoria
9. Little Busters!
10. Katawa Shoujo

satelit_utara

12 years ago

1 - Clannad
2 - Tsukihime
3 - Fate Stay Night
4 - Muv Luv Alternative
5 - Kara no Shoujo
6 - G senjou no maou
7 - Little Busters!
8 - canvas 2
9 - Kamidori Alchemy Meister
10 - Sengoku Rance

stickman070791

12 years ago

1 - Saya no Uta
2 - Fate/Stay Night
3 - Umineko No Naku Koro Ni
4 - G-Senjou no Maou
5 - Tsukihime
6 - Sharin no Kuni, Himawari no Shoujo
7 - Demonbane
8 - Fortune Arterial
9 - Sengoku Rance
10 - OMGWTFOTL

Guilty pleasure - The X-change series

Littshepkid

12 years ago

These lists are laughable.

amorim

12 years ago

Littshepkid wrote...

These lists are laughable.

Thank you for the contribuition! Now, if you don't want to post your list please refrain from posting on this thread.

Littshepkid

12 years ago

amorim wrote...

Littshepkid wrote...

These lists are laughable.

Thank you for the contribuition! Now, if you don't want to post your list please refrain from posting on this thread.

http://vndb.org/v1143
http://vndb.org/v1474
http://vndb.org/v2622
http://vndb.org/v238
http://vndb.org/v87

I only put 5 I don't really have that many "favorites"
I played only 100 VN's

BagMan

12 years ago

[size=14]Well I haven't played all that many VNs but here's my top 9 (essentially nothing else I've played stands out as much as these 9 so it would be pointless adding a sub-par tenth)

1. Steins;Gate
2. CROSS+CHANNEL
3. Little Busters!
4. Clannad
5. G-Senjou no Maou
6. The Muv-Luv trilogy (Extra+Unlimited+Alternative)
7. Rewrite
8. Fate/Stay Night
9. Da Capo[/h]

castor212

12 years ago

Updating my top 10 of list:

Fate/stay night
G-senjou no Maou
Saya no Uta
Ever17 -the out of infinity-
Muv-Luv Alternative
Steins;Gate
Utawarerumono
Little Busters! Finished 3/3 8
Osananajimi wa Daitouryou ~My girlfriend is the President.~ Finished 3/3 8
Rewrite
Sharin no Kuni, Himawari no Shoujo

meluvulongtime

12 years ago

English Translated VNs

1. Muv-Luv Alternative (simply the best, no question; the culmination of 2 subpar VNs being used to set the stage)
2. Sharin no Kuni, Himawari no Shoujo (only VN I couldn't stop playing besides MLA)
3. Sengoku Rance (addictive SRPG with good and plentiful H-scenes)
4. Swan Song (aesthetically beautiful and underrated imo)
5. Steins;Gate (would've been top 3 if it had H-scenes, it's criminal for there not to be Kurisu H-scenes)
6. G-Senjou no Maou (not as good as Sharin, but not much worse; the difference is practically indistinguishable)
7. Fate/Stay Night (the gold standard for exciting still fight scenes)
8. Ever 17 -the out of infinity- (same as Steins;Gate)
9. Monmusu Quest 1&2 (quality of plot and art not good enough to put higher, but funny and charming despite its limitations)
10. Saya no Uta (excellent story, although short and simple)

Honorable Mention

Clannad (after-story is good, but too many long, uninteresting routes with unclear choices and no H-scenes)
Katawa Shoujo (definitely charming, but the plot and music are not adequate to put it above any of the top 10)
Utawarerumono (good, but not better than the top 10; ranking suffers from being an older game)
Eien no Aselia (fun gameplay, but plot is lacking and gameplay gets repetitive)
Kono Yo no Hate de Koi wo Utau Shoujo YU-NO (excellent plot, but incredibly frustrating gameplay makes walkthrough a necessity; lacks the quality of art and music found in newer games)

Post Reply

Pages 123