Overall, this had some of the most believable romances I've ever seen in a VN. There's some definite archetypal casting, but it doesn't feel forced or cliched. There's good development between all the characters and a respectable feel for elapsed time. When the sex did come- it was always in the right setting with the right mood. It didn't feel forced, rushed, nor did it feel like it took excessively long to get to that point.
Chie was also my favorite, but that's a lot because she fit my one of my favorite archetypes: The buddy who's like one of the guys. I don't mean she's a tomboy- she's still got her femininity, but it's not flaunted.
just a heads up, there is a 4th ending available after completing the 3 main routes- it's an alternate version of the Kirari ending.
Minor spoilers:
I'm guessing you stopped playing the Kirari path because it's excessively sad. The 4th ending is still sad, but it's not the terrible tragedy that the first kirari ending was.
and yea, too bad the hcg weren't that awesome but that's not really the point of an eroge like this one right ^^ ?
Funny you bring this up, since I was just looking over the h-scenes the other day. I think that maybe they HCG was a little
too good, actually... like maybe I oughtn't be intruding on those lovers' private moment. I was really turned on, but I need something a little dirty, naughty or otherwise taboo to really get off. The first h-scene totally did it for me, but the others made me feel warm and fuzzy rather than hot and bothered.