Excellent game! The scenery is amazing, great voice acting, same great dynamic and smooth animations from GTA IV, and my favorite game this year. There are so many things to do that you shouldn't ever be bored when you want to take a break from the story.
Free roam is a blast. It seems kind of slow and boring, but with some friends it's the most fun I've had for a long time.
I hate writing ending spoilers this early because no one goes back to read them when they finish, but I really gotta get this off my chest.
Ending spoils
Who knew that your farm was in the Great Plains the whole time? Any other game would have made it a cutscene, but here we get to ride back to John's home and see his family. Just a beautiful moment, I loved this part. Then you get a few more missions and get your farm back up and running.
The game should have ended there, in my opinion. I hate when the main character dies especially one who I really like, like John Marston. Getting revenge as his son was nice, but it just won't be the same.
I'll get over it, doesn't change my opinion of how great this game is.