Kaimax wrote...
Alex~kun wrote...
It just made me wonder if the person who made this list actually played these games at all, or just found some pictures of ones that looked off, made some quick notes on each, then picked six, and said they were the weirdest.
Well, it is from a perspective of someone who never played a VN, of course it's going to be very different to us who has played more. All of those are translated, meaning that the writer has very limited knowledge to dig.
If you try to put yourself into the writer's POV, All those games are insane for a "dating sim". In the eyes of those who don't play a VN, they think most dating sims are just Tokimeki memorials. It's even clearer that the writer doesn't know that VNs are more than just dating sims.
So, it's not about YMK getting the short stick, but to the eyes of a non player it's one of the most "weirdest" concepts that a dating sim can have.
I see your point, and I agree, but that's exactly why I have a problem with this list. If it was from someone that understood and played VNs, or someone with a dry sense of humor, then I wouldn't have too much of a problem with it, and might be willing to see them half way at their point.
But it's not, and that irks me to some small amount. It's a likely case that I might be over-thinking or taking it too seriously, but at the same time, for example, on the off chance that if someone stumbled upon this list with a slight interest in trying VNs, or were just getting into them, they'd be missing out on some great pieces of work if this list were to turn them away to some titles, and that kinda sucks.
I don't know. I can agree to disagree, or whatever it may be, but besides one game on that list, I very much don't agree with this list, and in turn, don't find it particularly humorous.