Okay, finished (the true route for Seinarukana and Ein no Aselia: The Third Destination) Seinarukana Special Edition. My impression? Definitely worth it's value to be put up as one of the best ever epics ever created. The entire series can be summed up with just one word to know it's incredible value: Epic. Absolutely epic.
Before I start reviewing, let's talk about some of the impressions I've had for Ein no Aselia (The original one, not Third Destination). Ein no Aselia is a very innocent, light hearted themed story despite its attempt at certain points to sound grim, particularly during your first playthrough. However, you would later discover you can overturn that certain tragedy by selecting the right choices during your second playthrough, and thus what I meant by innocent. It's comparable to a high school romance novel where reality doesn't seem to have a consequence on the character, and they always seem to get their way.
I'd like to compare Ein no Aselia to Fate/Stay Night. Some spoilers here, so don't open if you haven't read either VNs:
Ein no Aselia and F/SN's Unlimited Blade Works arc are incredible similar. Both stories told of a protagonist who abandoned everything to become a hero, and was completely unrewarded and even cursed for their efforts. In Ein no Aselia, by becoming an Eternal, Yuuto and Aselia are doomed to be forever forgotten by their friends, family, and comrades, and absolutely everything they've done to save their world. However, Yuuto and Aselia had each other, and later even gave birth to Euphoria, and that was a positive source of happiness and relief for their lives.
UBW's Arc is also rather similar. Emiya Shirou strive hard to become a hero for his dream to save everyone, and died with a smile in the end even though he was presumably betrayed and executed by the people he trusted. But his life was not meant to end there, or rather he was not granted the death everyone should have. He became the World's Cleaner and is responsible for fixing the world's distortion for all eternity. No matter where he was sent, only death and sorrow awaits. There was no salvation, there was no hope. He could only keep on fighting until god knows when. An eternity.
A similar end for both protagonists, but with such a huge difference between their lives that it's almost unimaginable. And after that, it's hard to imagine that Yuuto and Aselia can have so little regrets about being forgotten by everyone, that they had never once thought what an eternal life would mean for their child. The outcome of Ein no Aselia was as happy as it was somewhat childish.
Now, to start the review. Seinarukana fixed almost every problem of that. I was surprised to see that Seinarukana - despite the rather lucky happy end and all - has an appropriate dose of realism that makes the story incredibly good to read. It's not excessively grim like Muramasa where everything was painted in such a wicked light that it's hard NOT to feel like the entire world is evil, and yet not so lacking in realism that everything read like a fairy tale or soap opera. It's just... appropriate.
The protagonist Nozomi is subjected to a series of problems, and each one of them introduced the consequences properly instead of the incredible usually seen 'as long as we go towards the light everything will be juuuust fine, teehee~' drama. There's a heck tonne of comedy and tsukomi of course, but that's common in most VNs. There's even a certain world introduced that had such terrifying implications that you could literally a chill up your backbone. And even right up till the end, despite the protagonist seemingly accept his fate and had cast away all of his regrets to follow his own beliefs, the Assort chapters properly tells you that that is not the case, and he like any other humans always had that shadow of doubt that's constantly gnawing at him from the inside.
There's another thing that I like really much about the Seinarukana story, and that's completion. They did not cut corners. Each story was painstakingly constructed to as complete as possible. Most of the character's story was told - well you can't cover everyone, but most of them - was covered with such visible effort that it's hard not to respect the writer. Usually in an SRPG the creators would choose to put in a few minutes of story and jump right to the next stage while making little to no sense other than, "WE HAVE TO PROTECT *INSERT HERE*!", but Seinarukana did not do that.
The Assort chapters were especially satisfying to read. They are the stories after the ending of Seinarukana. Nanashi/Akatsuki's story is well tailored and incredibly adorable, Talia/Sonosuke's story talks about Talia's doubts and Sonosuke's open and straightforward attitude when faced with a tough decision, and the final one between Reme and Nozomi - ironically the weakest story out of the 3 Assorts even though they're the protagonist - tells the brief story about Nozomi's condition and encounter with 2 Law Eternals.
The combined content of the PSP and PC version is MASSIVE as it is incredibly SATISFYING, and while not as well constructed and perfect as Baldr Sky, had given me the same kind of nostalgia. This is truly the most epic VNs ever produced by the company and deserves a 10 out of 10 for its story.
The SRPG can be a total ass though; I am extremely dissatisfied with the fact that only All Rounders can change their skills during battle, and that too must be done through a series of unnecessary, reducible actions. It makes some fights harder than it should be and ultimately forced me to give up challenging at Chapter 8 because I simply don't have that much time to waste, and used the Auto Win patch to go through except during boss fights.
In short, good game, kind of annoying SRPG, okay 3D effects, and an amazing story.
Now, to the rather short VN Aselia: The Third Destination. 10 out of 10.
... Why? This tells the story of Yuuto and Aselia, after being sent into a world under orders to do something, discovers that Aselia has become pregnant.
Now, this VN is AMAZING. Completely discarding its predecessor's optimism, The Third Destination takes on a largely dark atmosphere and tells the bloody tale of war between the Chaos and Law Eternals, as shown through the various hardships experienced by the protagonists. It also tells of the brief encounter between all three No.1 Eternal Swords, which ultimately resulted in Narukana's sealing.
This story is grim. Very grim. To put this spoilerless-ly, There's a total bitch (I'm sorry for the harsh word, but I really cannot find another word to describe her -_-") at the Law Eternal's camp, also one of the No.1 Eternal Swords, who is determined to kill Yuuto and Aselia because they're interfering with her plans, and Yuuto and Aselia lost the fight despite being able to escape with their lives. There was a scene so shocking that my heart literally stopped there for a second. It was only through luck that they had managed to survive in the end. The story remained dark and even chose to tell about Euphoria's birth and what happened to the protagonists with nothing but a few CGs, DURING THE ENDING CUTSCENE. The epilogue was given to the Law Eternals instead, where a dark future is foretold and highly implied the coming of a sequel. Amazing, amazing execution. Its rare to see that a VN can stay true to its intended atmosphere from the beginning till the end.
This pack? Amazing. I would buy it if the custom ain't such a bitch in my country and blocks all 18+ stuff. The SRPG is rather cumbersome and old, but still amazing. I highly recommend anyone who wouldn't mind wasting a few weeks of their free time to play this, because it is definitely worth its value, and more.