HappyDia01 wrote...
I didn't read it, but I'll give you a few tips on why I didn't -
Anyway, as it is now this piece of work is pretty much unreadable.
Clearly, this is no masterpiece, but we should welcome all who want to practice or enjoy writing. Reviews like this, however, can seem a little to harsh and can prevent the people they are critiquing from writing more and practicing. On that note, I'm going to point out some of your points in your critique and explain how I feel about it.
HappyDia01 wrote...
You're constantly leaving off punctuation, or just plain not capitalizing the first letter of each sentence. This is grade school stuff.
Not if someone is learning English for the first time. From what I have heard, English is the hardest language to learn as an adult. With that aside, good grammar should be practiced. Also, by adding "This is grade school stuff," it seems to have added an insult and strays from objectivity, which is the main goal of a critique.
HappyDia01 wrote...
You need to work on your grammar. There are mistakes, and it is distracting. A sentence shouldn't stand alone unless you're making a dramatic statement of some sort by singling it out. It needs to be part of a paragraph. However, when you're switching speakers make sure to always start a new paragraph otherwise it will be confusing. Switch up where you place your sentences so it doesn't become stale - place them in the front, middle, and/or back of differentiating paragraphs to keep people's attention attached to the dialogue. You're either writing a script or you're not, so don't just lazily throw unattached dialogue one after the other and then lambaste the reader with paragraphs afterwards.
It's not really distracting, unless if you focus on the grammar too much. The sentence structure is mostly right, but he should focus on his paragraph structure. It's not really necessary because the author will eventually work it out as he writes more. I do believe he does switch the speakers with new paragraphs throughout, so it's really unnecessary to add that sentence in your critique. Also, you might want to check your own writing if you want to appear professional:
HappyDia01 wrote...
Also, learn where to put commas and where to leave them off. Also, try not to repeat the same word multiple times in a paragraph. It is just sloppy writing. For instance, you did it here: "The warning I gave Kenta was more because of my experience with Utako-nee. I was inexperienced(,) and ..." It isn't EXACTLY the same word, but it is still highly repetitive. If you thought out and matured your sentences ahead of time by thinking through exactly how you want to convey your message(,) then it wouldn't be necessary for you to emphasize the same thing multiple times.
I pointed this paragraph out because you start two sentences in a row with, "Also," which detracted my attention a bit, so you could either conjoin the sentences or write them differently. You could keep a good structure throughout your critique if you get rid of words and phrases that aren't needed, like "just" from "It is just sloppy writing." You can also keep good structure if you either use conjunctions for every place you can, or never use them; this is a subtle grammar practice that actually helps the audience while reading. This last paragraph would look like this if I wrote it:
You should practice where you put commas and where to leave them off, and you should not repeat the same word multiple times in a paragraph. It's just sloppy writing. For instance, "The warning I gave Kenta was more because of my experience with Utako-nee. I was inexperienced(,) and ..." It isn't exactly the same word, but it's still highly repetitive. If you thought out your sentences before you wrote them and how you would like to convey the message, then it wouldn't be necessary to emphasize the same thing multiple times.
Overall, you should check the grammar in your sentences and work on sentence/paragraph structure. It's pretty toned, but could use some help. I would also work towards a more objective point-of-view to appear more professional as you are critiquing someone who needs help with their writing. I hope this has helped you.