By the way, they are all staying at the 2nd floor before the 1st Murder.
Ignore the 1st floor - it has no use (no I'm just lazy to make another character)
Well, I know Melody is one of the murderers, and that's for a fact. And I know this, because when they looked in the bathroom, there was glass on the floor. If she had been pushed or fell through the window, there would be no glass shards inside the bathroom, and all the shards would be located on the outside of the building.
What if there's someone hiding in the bathroom?
and there were glass shards..or fragments
Well, just replace my word shard for fragment. I thought it was shards, reread, and it was fragments.
Oh sorry for the late late reply XD There are window fragments in the bathroom
#1: When he went to go pee, he killed Karen using some type of item. ((At first I thought it would be a piece of glass, but he could have used a razor in the bathroom, or something else like that.))
#2: William pushed Johnny out the window when the kitchen went dark.
#3: William was the only one watching over Melody while she was in the bathroom when Nina was in Karen's room. After he pushed her out the open window, he smashed the window, either shutting it too hard, or breaking the glass himself.
#4: He pushed Nina down the stairs, and made it look as if he got pushed as well.
#5: He killed himself in the Kitchen using whatever utensil he had at hand.
#1: When he went to go pee, he killed Karen using some type of item. ((At first I thought it would be a piece of glass, but he could have used a razor in the bathroom, or something else like that.))
#2: William pushed Johnny out the window when the kitchen went dark.
#3: William was the only one watching over Melody while she was in the bathroom when Nina was in Karen's room. After he pushed her out the open window, he smashed the window, either shutting it too hard, or breaking the glass himself.
#4: He pushed Nina down the stairs, and made it look as if he got pushed as well.
#5: He killed himself in the Kitchen using whatever utensil he had at hand.
I'll deny your theory, "William didn't commit suicide"
#1: She was last upstairs before she screamed.
#2: She pushed Johnny out the window when it was dark, and must have hit herself on one of the chairs.
#3: She broke through the window of the bathroom and killed Melody.
#4: She pushed William down the stairs, and accidentally cracked open her skull.
#5: She killed William in the kitchen using the utensils there. After which, she died from brain injury and blood lose.
#1: She was last upstairs before she screamed.
#2: She pushed Johnny out the window when it was dark, and must have hit herself on one of the chairs.
#3: She broke through the window of the bathroom and killed Melody.
#4: She pushed William down the stairs, and accidentally cracked open her skull.
#5: She killed William in the kitchen using the utensils there. After which, she died from brain injury and blood lose.