d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
Several things about this. First, what does she mean by him
always coming to that spot when in the previous paragraph, you mention that he hasn't been there in years? It makes it sound like he goes there all the time.
It's never written that he hasn't been there in years. It's written that "He stood on a rock at the edge of the beach, just as he had in
years past." That could very well mean every year, and is actually enforced by one of the last sentences where he says "I really can’t wait to come back again next year." Clearly the school finds going to a beach within their low budget for summer trips.
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
Second, I have an idea of your personal preferences by now, but I still can't help but point out that here you don't use Airi's name despite the fact that this story is written in omniscient.
Yes, I write them in descriptively before I write in their names in this instance. I did the same with Kenji, ". . .that one would have been what
the boy chose." This is because names are all well and good but if a reader doesn't know that Airi is a girl's name, and beyond that, that it is assigned to a girl as well, I would like that to be made clear what a subject is before a name is assigned, but as you said, that is my personal preference.
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
Third, a in 'A girl . . .' should be lower case. You don't capitalize words you wouldn't otherwise capitalize following dialogue that ends with a question mark.
Not even if I intend it to be the beginning of a new sentence? I don't intend that sentence to carry on after the quotation, that was truthfully my intent.
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
Fourth, good ol' show don't tell. You tell me that Airi eventually grows bored, but what does she do when she grows bored? However, you do mention after that that she has a lollipop and is manipulating it with her tongue, but if that's what she does when she's bored, why bother telling me that she's bored and then show that she's bored?
Personal preference, I feel words convey in that instant rather than the action of the inaction of boredom. I felt it was enough to justify not only her current archetype as the tag-along to Kenji's reminiscence, but also perhaps to reinforce an image of her that a lollipop helps craft, which is childish innocence, and playfulness to an extent.
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
I don't know what it is, but there's something about the 'Simple, Airi' part that sounds fake. Almost as if the author was looking for a way to squeeze her name in.
Although it does serve as an opportunity to introduce her name, I think it's quite a normal thing to do to use a friends name on occasion when addressing them. Nice try, though, but your agenda of beginning narration with names already set won't sway me, at least it's too late for this story.
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
You'll have ask Logo or someone else who really knows their grammar, but I think 'collapsing the sand . . .' actually modifies the wave in this structure, which obviously isn't what you were going for.
You may be correct here, I had some frustrations with this sentence in this regard, including the repetitious use of "sand" that I couldn't avoid at the time.
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
At this point, I'm wondering just how big the crab is and how Kenji missed it. Last we heard, he was looking at her, and I imagine the crab coming up right in front of her. I guess I'm confused on where everything is physically laid out on the beach. I'm not sure where the cave is either.
I guess I only can suggest to utilize your imagination for those small details, as they tend to be too small to address with a low word limit, but if she saw it and he didn't, you're right in assuming that she was seeing something that he wasn't, and the most likely explanation for this is that she is behind him. If you want to know the crab's size, I think it's pretty important that you understand that it's a Kenyan Mangrove crab, also known as a cave demon. It has massive claws that can rip a tank apart. Kenji and Airi were lucky to have left that cave alive without a fatal
Crab Battle.
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
I believe that comma should be deleted.
You might be right here, I'm not used to thinking of the em dash as a punctuation mark that could replace a comma and end a quotation.
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
If I did this, I'd split it up into two sentences because it can be bit awkward to have big strings attached to dialogue though it isn't too bad here. Also, I feel that the action that follows the dialogue is important enough that it deserves it's own sentence.
It's my personal opinion that a good sex scene is just like a good fight scene in that you want to give enough details to paint a picture in the reader's head, but you don't want to do too much because then it gets boring to read. I think you do a pretty good job here accept for one thing.
She gasped as her arms wrapped around his neck and shoulders.
This sentence kinda makes it sound like her arms have a will of their own.
Also, Shouta forces himself on Yui, but if they entered the cave so they wouldn't get spotted, why did they stop at the entrance? Why not head further back? Aside from the fact that if they were to go too far, they'd bump into Kenji and Airi.
I agree with what you say here comparing a sex and fight scene. I think if I had to explain why they were attached, I'd say that I didn't separate the first sentence because I wanted to have them relevant to each other to attach the fact that his remark was intended to be a double entendre, though this is subtle. It might very well still show this effect and be more clear with them separated.
As for her arms having a will of their own, our bodies acting on reflex due to stimulation can be argued to have a very similar effect. It may just sound better with "and" instead of "as" in that instance, though. That's a consideration.
Also, an easy explanation for why they didn't go further in is because it's quite dark, that area of the beach was deserted until they got there regardless since I never addressed the presence of anyone else in the area aside from Kenji and Airi since the beginning, and Kenji and Airi were already there, obviously. They're considerate friends.
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
. . . feeling what they imagined it must have been like to be drunk or on some mind-altering drug.
This is really awkward for me to read.
It sounds fairly normal to me as I read it aloud. Can you elaborate?
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
As they were traveling back with the class, two friends of theirs caught up with them.
This makes it sound as if they're already on the bus heading back to the school whereas this sentence
The anxiety between the four of them became a bit more tolerable as they entered the bus together.
reveals that they're just now boarding the bus.
This is because you assume that the words "traveling back with the class" means traveling by vehicle home alongside the rest of the class, but if you read the words as if they mean "traveling by walking back to the main beach in order to be alongside ("with") the rest of the class," then that assumption doesn't hinder your comprehension. I think the previous sentence "They arrived just in time for a snack before everyone was to board buses back to town." helps solidify that they had yet to board the buses. Apologies if this could have been made more clear.
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
Nice bookends for this story, with how it starts with a word Kenji would use and ends with a word Airi would use.
As I said before in my initial post, I feel as if Kenji and Airi should have recognized Yui and Shouta. They all seem to be pretty close friends.
In retrospect, it's really obvious that trolly crab is an excuse to get them in the cave so they can peep on their friends.
Thanks, I was particularly happy the bookends served the story well. It starts off with Kenji as the focal character, but I didn't want to write in first person and also to reinforce their equality of importance in the story. I was very pleased that they helped in this regard, in my eyes anyway.
I will admit that you're right, it's quite a stretch for them not to recognize them, especially when speech is used. This unfortunately was a result when I made a drastic change in the plot. Originally, Kenji and Airi were going to be playing around a small town the school had sent them to on a trip. They were to play around in the back alleys and find their way behind a bar, then a grown man and woman were to bust out of the back door, trapping Kenji and Airi like how it was here, and then just go at it with each other. It may have served the concept better of forcing images of growing up and leaving adolescence behind on their innocent minds, but I couldn't justify why a school would allow a class to run around a town, in dirty areas and red-light districts, without supervision. A normal beach was just nicer to write about description-wise anyway, but I guess you can see how the plot might suffer from that shift.
I still wanted the erotic parts in as a symbol of one of the greatest drives that progress one away from adolescence, but I guess a substitution of classmates was less than ideal. I remember a conversation I had with a friend in middle school who was telling me they were doing sexual stuff with their significant other at the time and remember being really weirded out about it, especially after learning in health class about all those icky diseases you get from doing it. I suppose I was writing a bit from personal experience there.
Something about a scary topic that's a symbol of growing up forced onto individuals going through puberty, I guess that was the main inspiration behind this piece. Even though the images were forced, they still wanted to progress at their own pace, and I guess that's one of the things I liked most about my piece this time around.
Thank you for the commentary, I really do appreciate it. Although I can defend some points, the very fact that I have to defend some of them reminds me that I still need to improve certain areas to keep it in high quality in order for it to be as appealing as possible, eliminating areas of confusion wherever I can. So thank you very much for that. I'll comment on yours shortly.