Good god, it's been years since the last time I've been here. Yes, I am NessaVerne, but changed my account due to forgetting it even existed in the first place orz. Even though I didn't passed the contest, I'm still here for nostalgia sake (lmao).
Dawn_of_Dark wrote...
It is a cute story.
I made this out to be a story about a couple in a open relationship. It's a difference in culture, but relationship like this is traditionally frowned upon in my Asian standards, so I may not interpret this as well as the others. I personally think that such a open relationship isn't the best example to show what you wanted to show in this story. In another words, I think love is not truly understood by people who are in a open relationship, contrary to what you try to make out to be. So, I was also confused about what was the moral of the story until you pointed it out at the end of the story and in the comments above. Young people always complain about the bound of society's discipline and standards, but they also need to know that the bounds has existed for a long time and they exist for a reason. That is to say, I think you could have made the message in this story stronger and more visible to convince the readers, because as you have read, none of us who read your story was entirely sure what you was trying to say.
It could be just me.
About the grammar aspect, I think it's pretty good. A few grammatical mistakes. You would also want to work on your cohesiveness of some sentences and your dialogue.
All in all, credit is given when it's due, so I think it's not a bad job. Good luck to you in the contest.
Yes, you get where the inspiration came from. Relationships in Asian is generally even more conservative, but it's exactly the message I tried to convey in questioning the society's outlook in open relationships. And yes, thank you so much for the feedback back then.
xhimitsu wrote...
I was left with a feeling of:
What is the moral?
Are they friends with benefits?
Do the guy love the girl back?
Are they just young people exploring their sexual desires?
It was cute and sweet and you can feel that the characters are close, but close as in a relationship? If so are they knowingly cheating on each other? Perhaps to try different options in life than staying with their first love forever? Or are they perhaps friends with benefits who might and might not want to take the next step into a relationship? I was a bit confused and had so many questions I wanted an answer too. Otherwise I think it was a cute romance story, would have loved more info about the characters but else fine~
I deliberately made it ambiguous in how they view their own relationships, because they are equally confused in how 'love' mean for themselves. Thank you so much.
It's crazy to re-read this story again by today's perspective, but some things didn't change even when three years has passed. I made a hentai doujinshi with my friend this year. It's recently released in the comics section and of course, I incorporated the same view I had when writing the above story in this manga too. I hope you guys like it, so here's the link of the manga we made:
https://www.fakku.net/hentai/after-hours-english