crazr and d back for the 10th anniversary. Good to see both of you!
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
I think my biggest issue with the story is it takes longer than it feels like it should for me to understand the plot. The first half makes it seem that the main conflict is Alice surviving in a harsh environment. That is definitely a goal of hers, but it's not the focus of the story. By the end (correct me if I'm wrong), it seems the main conflict is Alice being lonely, which gets solved by her asking to join Chris.
Unfortunately, this is very well justified criticism imo. I really wanted to sell the situation that they were in, but it is correct that the major overarching focus was the idea of companionship. Not necessarily romance, but people who would be willing to share in your journey, even (or especially) when a situation seems hopeless.
This is nitpicky, but if they're in a building, is there ventilation for the smoke from the fire to air out of the room? Kind of a problem if not.
I did not consider this. I could make up a reason, but in the moment I overlooked it. I shall try to remember this in the future.
I'll use this line to mention something I've noticed about the way you handle dialogue. You tend to make the line after the dialogue its own sentence, and while you can do this, you usually do it with dialogue tags, which usually aren't their own sentences. For example, I would edit the above line to look like:
"Ah, you're awake," an unfamiliar voice called out to her.
This is very helpful. Thank you!
It's too bad you weren't able to submit anything. I'd have loved to see what you could've written. Thanks for reading!
crazr wrote...
Overall, and enjoyable read. Good job, Nine!
First of all, thanks for all the kind words. I'm glad you read it!
Finally, on a completely different note, I like these recurring character names (or is it the characters as well?) that you use. It’s a nice touch that reminds me it’s your writing.
The stories I tend to write are almost always focused on a kind of 'personal' feeling that I want to convey—things like love, companionship, loneliness, and grief. I try to bridge the reader so they understand and empathize. So, I tend to have recurring characters because it's easier for me to get into a certain frame of mind. The characters are based loosely on people I know and understand, so it's easy for me to picture the dynamics between them.
This is why you see Alice and Chris often paired as friends, and Peter and Vy paired as lovers.
Anyways, I'm glad you took the time to read it! Thank you!