Going on a date with my girlfriend and passing as a girl with a toy right up against my prostate the entire time, and only me and my girlfriend know oh my god thats so hot
I like that title. Goes very well with the Vanilla tag, and is the perfect sequel title to the previous one that was "My Cute Girlfriend"!
How nice of that one guy to ask if he was doing all right...Though I think he probably sussed out what was going on partway through when she told him not to worry.