I would have said Code Geass but after watching that anime its one of my favorites but id say that Naruto is pretty overrated in Western countries since in most Manga sites its number #1 the show is good though but i really hate the dub now than i did when i was younger
Naruto, since I seriously cant figure out whats with super bloodlines and crap. Story is decent, but i want to smash Naruto in the head witha sledgehammer. There is a limit how stupid you can be.
The original Full Metal Alchemist anime, I prefer the Manga/Brotherhood storyline, albeit the first half of FMA I found to be very enjoyable and better than the manga in spots.
Ouran Highschool Host Club I find overrated. Everyone gushes over it and says it's funny and everything but I found nothing funny about this show at all. It was over-done comedy with a bunch of queers and it didn't seem to have a story either. Just uneccessary drama and comedy all the way through. I just don't see the appeal over it. And as for people saying Clannad, sorry to say but you're exaggerating. It's good for what it is and at least I actually felt for the characters. It's only that cheesy ending of After Story that threw it all off for me, but I do like it and it DOES have values to it, unlike other animes I know that are just there to look entertaining "cough Naruto cough" I don't like Fullmetal Alchemist either. I find that overrated. Sorry :/
I have to say that after the first three sets of pokemon it started getting retarded. There is such a thing as too much. Personally, I adore the first season of pokemon, and i will always be a fan of it, but the new episodes make me want to cry.