This is going to take a while....
First of all separate the movies and ovas from the series. And the categorize them by the dominate genre. For example: Steins;gate should be labeled as a mystery or
science fiction anime.
//basic list
// MAL hyperlinks will be placed on all titles, if you want a summary - go there!
PERSONAL FAVORITES
Bakemonogatari -
and sequels
Bakemonogatari is 15 episode harem anime from 2009, produced by Shaft. It marks the beginning of the 'tropes' Shaft is known for their later works. It's also written by Nisio Isin, famous for his work Katanagatari.
What makes Bakemono different from other harem shows is it's eccentric style it gets by the absence of unimportant characters and the choice of colors, usually leaning for few very bright colors.
If you aren't familiar with Nisio Isin, he has made a name for himself for his lengthy and witty dialogues which are both present in Bakemono. This is the reason why
you might not like it.
Scenes sometimes stretching for several minutes with nothing but dialogues. What makes this a godsend is how well written the dialogues and interactions really are.
So get ready for 15 episodes of verbal abuse, puns going over your head and sexually suggestive but uncomfortable scenes. Hitagimuhuwaifu
Welcome To The NHK
Welcome to the NHK is a 24 episode psychological anime from 2006. It addresses issues with obsessions mentioning; drug abuse, online gaming, anime and porn.
I think it portrays a scared hikikomori very well.
It might even motive you to do something with your life
Puru puru puruin ah puru puru puruin ah puru puru puruin ah puru puru puruin ah puru puru puruin ah puru puru puruin ah puru puru puruin ah puru puru puruin ah puru puru puruin ah puru puru puruin ah puru puru puruin ah puru puru puruin ah
Mushishi
Mushishi is a 26 episode mystery anime from 2005, produced by Artland. This is a very calm and relaxing show. If you're allergic to drama then this probably isn't for you.
Mushishi uses a new type of animal called mushi to explain all the abnormal things happening to the people in Japan around Sengoku period. But most of the time you can easily remove mushi from the formula and replace it with neglect
or other similar relationship issues
(for a lack of better word). And this is where the strengths of Mushishi lies. Namely Ginko's ways of restoring relationships and trying his best to do the morally correct thing even if it means sacrificing something for it.
Great Teacher Onizuka
Like Waar said a long time ago "After GTO you feel like punching god, because you can"
(or something like that)
Great Teacher Onizuka is a 43 episode comedy anime from 1999. About a former biker gang leader trying to become Japan's best teacher. He's giving a class filled with delinquents to deal with and he does so using some rather unorthodox teaching methods.
After every episode you'll feel pumped up as hell. I forgot to mention that it's hilarious. Try Golden Boy if you want a similar experience with a smaller episode count but a bigger focus on pervertedness. MY CRESTA!!!
OTHER FAVORITES
// These are all very popular.
Someone else write something about them please....
Nichijou
One of the funniest animöjs.
Neon Genesis Evangelion
The quintessential anime of 1990's. I liked it a lot. Even if it can feel a little bit dated.
Spice and wolf
>I'm watching it for the economics.
I'd understand if this didn't make it to the list but come on it's Horo.
Angel Beats
ALL ABOARD THE FEELSTRAIN CHUU CHUU. [size=5]Dead Girls Monster[/h]
Fate/Zero
EVERYDAY UNTIL YOU LIKE IT!
Cowboy Bebop
Glorious Jazz music.
Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
Penis.
Clannad
Everyone likes After Story more.
Durarara!!
You're watching this because of Izaya and Shizou.
Baccano
Excellent story telling and music.
Puella Magi Madoka Magica
This is a story about happy magical magical girls OH WAI-
Code Geass
Awesome introduction. Great action scenes with strategy elements to it. One of the villains half way through the first season is very lacking, he's just a terrible villain. And the second season will also come with mixed opinions as it feels distanced from where the original story was going. But boy does the ending make up for it.
Katanagatari
Very likable characters. Interesting arcs. Everything is just good.
Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei
Comedy made by Shaft. A good one with that. Has the weird psychedelic stuff Shaft is known for.
The Tatami Galaxy
Samurai Champloo
Samurai anime with a slice of pop culture.
Usagi Drop
The second best thing next to Yotsuba. It's just adorable.
Ano Hi Mita Hana no Namae o Bokutachi wa Mada Shiranai
I HATE IT!
UNDERRATED (as by MAL's score)
Kemonozume
Kemonozume is a 13 episode supernatural romance anime from 2006, directed by Yuasa, Masaaki. The story is similar to that of Romeo and Juliet but it gets more complicated as the episode count increase. But the reason why you should even bother with Kemonzume is because of the unique (kinda sloppy looking) art style, looking similar to that of
Kill Bill. Try Tatami Galaxy and Kaiba of you like this, made by the same dude.
Steamboy
Excellent production with a interesting but shallow plot.
Haibane Renmei
Haibane Renmei is a 13 episode fantasy (with a bit of slice of life) anime, directed by Tokoro, Tomokazu, who also worked on Serial Experiment Lain and Hellsing Ultimate. If you like angel girls drinking tea, then this is perfect for you. That being said Haibane is much more than just a slice of life anime as you'll learn by Rakka's dark past. And that's the thing with Haibane is that it turns really gothic half way. Which I personally didn't mind.
Golden Boy
What if GTO was more perverse and funnier. Well here you have it. It's short but sweet.
Serial Experiments Lain
Well then. What the fuck did I just watch.
WATCHABLE
Azumanga Daioh
One of the earlier examples of slice of life anime. It has it's funny moments.
Darker Than Black
I was disappointed in this. I still enjoyed what I saw though. Action anime with supernatural powers involved.
Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai!
I laughed. Some people are really hateful towards this though.
Elfen Lied
It has really great action scenes but there's so few of them. And the rest is so shitty.
Panty and Stocking with Garterbelt
Made on american cartoons but with some anime tropes.
Kara no Kyoukai
Pretensions story with godlike production. It looks fucking awesome.
Hyouka
A decent slice of life anime with a bit of mystery in it. I'M CURIOUS!
Toradora
One of the better romance anime. It goes on for too long though but if you're into this sorta thing.
Beck
A really cool music anime. You follow a guitar and singer trying to get into a band and all that jazz. Slice of life btw.
MOVIES AND OVA
Wolf Children
Denpa Teki na Kanojo
Hotarubi no Mori e
Little Witch Academia
The Disapperance of Haruhi Suzuimya
Tekkon Kinkreet
5 Centimeters per Second
Cencoroll
Perfect Blue
Paprika
Tokyo Godfathers
Millennium Actress
Sword Of The Stranger
Grave of the Fireflies
Akira
Tsumiki no Ie
The Girl Who Leapt Through Time
The Cat Returns
An Studio Ghibli movie. Spin off of Whisper of the heart, another goodie.