who would win in a fight Spike or Revy

so would win in a fight between Spike from Cowboy Bebopp vs Revy from Black Laggon

Just had to call up two of my favorite characters huh?

Be a close one I bet. Spike is so smooth and in control (most of the time.) and Revy is, well, destructive. Well without going into too much detail, Imma go with Spike.

Enough of these topics please. Revy vs Riza at least left something to be discussed as the section name suggests but this is getting IB-worthy.

Normally, I would let the facts speak for themselves (as I did in the other "fantasy-matchup" thread) but in this case, a toss-up is in order. I'm bouncing with:

REVY by marksmanship
Spike by H2H

*flips a coin*

REVY wins

Bottomline: Waifu >>>>>>> Idol

@Das: Lol. Did you really believe that the other thread had any substance to begin with? I know you're aware of how much I hate this stuff(topics) but still I'd say just let them have a good round of fun. They're bound to get sick and tired of these sooner or later, hopefully.

If it was mano y mano combat, as in no vehicles, I'd think Revy would still win. She would never allow Spike to get close to her anyways, and dodging bullets is something that cannot be easily done. I never thought of Spike as having above-decent marksmanship.

I cast my vote for Revy.

defenetly spike

Bang. I rest my case.

Still say Train Heartnet.

In a straight-up gunfight I'd go with Revy.

Guns: Revy.she may be out of control with a gun, but she more marksmanship then Spike! Spike just shoots till he gets lucky...he also tends to drop his gun a lot.

Hand to Hand: Spike. He is smooth with his moves, ans knows how to get out of tight situations. Revy would just get pissed off at spike for fooling around during the battle lose her cool and give the advantage to spike.

It'll be a draw...

Guns - Spike is smart enough to avoid the fight and probably leg it if its too dangerous

H-2-H - Revy will get annoyingly pissed off at Spike and whip out her cutlasses which would mean that this will go back to the 'guns' rule.

Either way... no-one gets owned so therefore, it'll be a draw.
Tbh... These 2 characters dont really go well for a 'who would win thread', they're too different to begin with. Need something with a more common ground.

He destroyed the whole syndicate on his own with one glass eye. If he had full vision and full arms you are so dead. Revy has nothing to lose wild yet artistic in her way of fighting. But I will have to say Spike because of his veteranship and also because he knows how to strategize if he can't kill someone with just guns and roses.

hand to hand.....She took on the terminator maid and went fist for fist till dawn.She also handled the dude who could slice a bullet in half and shenghua who is an expert with blades on almost every other mission.

Revy knows strategy too

A better VS topic would be revy vs Rotton the wizard lol

Spike obviously, I dont even feel the need to explain the reasons for my choice in depth.

Revy can barely street fight, Spikes got genuine fighting skills. (Thats all I want to say) *Tired*

I think I'm going to have to go with Spike. Revy is probably on par in the experience department with Spike. She's probably got better dexterity, meaning better aim and faster dodges. But Spike's got tactics and is also quite aggressive which can be a deadly combo.



Black Lagoon is Cowboy Bebop lite. The Black Lagoon anime also ended with Revy saying "bang". Although I must say, Spike made it look cooler.

Revy does seem like she could hold her own but Spike just keeps surviving everything even the psycho who could stop bullets and packed RPG's next to shotguns under his coat

Of this I don't agree with. Black Lagoon goes much farther into human psychology and human darkness than Cowboy Bebop in my opinion. For some reason, much of Black Lagoon reminded me of Heart of Darkness in the setting and tone.

Haven't read Heart of Darkness but I've watched Apocalypse Now which was based on the book and Black Lagoon was no where near the level of psychological analysis of the human psyche as the movie. And when there were profound psychological moments present, it was only in a couple arcs. Not really enough to distinguish itself from the episodic action thriller Cowboy Bebop was.