BagMan wrote...
oneshott wrote...
artcellrox wrote...
The Machine Caliber may be mass produced, but they're still a mech. For all we know, BagMan may just want to claim some random one. And mass-produced mechs are claimable, because I'll be damned if I'm banning more well-known ones, like the GM and Zaku from Gundam.
By your wording it sounds like anyone can claim a Zaku then? That's fine, but even if Machine Calibers may be mass produced, they cannot function without the AI. And given that it's an AI, each one is of course unique. By my wording, I claimed a very specific Machine Caliber; Chamber.
BagMan wrote...
Sorry but I'm going tot have to dispute this, Chamber K6821 IS NOT the model of the mech it is in fact just the AI installed into the mech therefore your claim is less valid than mine
As stated before, the AI is an integral part of the Machine Caliber and cannot function without it. Though in hindsight you are probably correct, Chamber K6821 is not a model but a specific Machine Caliber, but if you want to dispute me, let's look at the wording of
your claim.
BagMan wrote...
Claiming the Machine Caliber from Suisei no Gargantia
Though I agree that Machine Calibers are mass produced, each one has an AI, making even a mass produced unit type unique. And since an AI is a distinct personality, and that a Machine Caliber cannot function without one, no single Machine Caliber is the same. Machine Caliber Chamber K6821 is unique even if compared to it's 6820 other siblings, so my claim to Machine Caliber Chamber K6821 is legitimate.
The prosecution rests.
To be honest I don't even care any more. I made the claim I meant to make if you want to pick holes in it that's fine but I still think that it's legitimate.