solutions10 wrote...
Shashin, you've convinced me to stick to right here. I figured it was a good idea, and now I've had some firsthand experience.
Today I received three Dakis: Two were peachskin, one was Rayon. I have to say, I was really, really put-off by the Rayon. It simply looks and feels like a downgrade from peachskin. It isn't nearly as soft or colorful.
I'm still waiting on the 2WT I invested in to see if it's as you say, and actually worth the rather significant price hike from peachskin. I'm a little skeptical, because the two peachskin I received were very surprisingly detailed and colorful, and also soft. They would suit me fine if they were my only choice.
But, again, I have one Sora no Otoshimono 2WT on its way, not sure when it will arrive. It's of Nymph, and it was...quite pricey. But I wanted first-hand experience, since I prefer personal experience to second-hand accounts, so we'll see. It definitely looks and sounds impressive from other accounts, but I'll be able to check it out for myself, probably within the end of the week.
One other thing worth mentioning, I think, is that it's very easy to get inexpensive plush stuffing that is far, far superior to the general offers that are made. They're pretty much the same size, and if you walk into a store that sells body pillows, they're clearly more comfortable and plush, but of perfectly adequate, if not identical, size.
Anyway, I'm looking forward to the 2WT. I might end up using it for art that I find particularly nice.
The issue of materials can be very complicated. The general pecking order would be 2WT/2WR -> Smooth Knit -> Peach Skin. However, that isn't absolute. Some people really like the feel of peach skin or smooth knit and don't necessarily care for 2WT (I've only met one person that didn't like 2WT and maybe two or three that would rate a different material above it.)
Another very important thing to consider is the manufacturer. I'm assuming you ordered the peach skin, rayon, and 2WT from the same bootlegger. You might end up liking their peach skin more than the 2WT, but that isn't necessarily representative of all 2WT. Once again, generally speaking, 2WT -> peach skin but the same principle of ranking applies to manufacturers. In fact, I'd think even more so, which is why legit covers are usually worth the price. A quality 2WT material (A&J, Seiren, P80's 2WR) will be vastly superior to the quality of a bootlegger's 2WT.
Bootleg covers can have fairly good quality in terms of color and print, but from my experience in seeing a ton of sample comparisons for bootleg and legit products, it's usually in the details that they lose out. I actually just came across a pretty good example of the differences the other day:
Bootleg: http://auctions.c.yimg.jp/img313.auctions.yahoo.co.jp/users/8/7/0/1/fryfishsky-img444x600-13525012707p1kmn37916.jpg
Legit:
http://www.pixiv.net/member_illust.php?mode=big&illust_id=26996588
Now, I personally think it's the red kimono that makes the cover but others might disagree. Even then, if you look hard enough you can see quite a few differences when it boils down to the details (shading, facial expression, boob shape, fluids, and so on.)
So depending on how you feel about the material, I'd say the $40 -> $80 jump is almost definitely worth it, but the $80 -> $150 jump is worth it to many as well (a lot of people in this thread actually started with bootlegs and moved to the legit goods with time.)
Which Nymph did you get and how much did it run you, if you don't mind me asking? :o
Yeah, that's probably some good advice on the stuffing, especially for those who can't find a body pillow in the right size for their covers (since almost all covers are 160x50 these days and the biggest pillow I've seen in a store was 130x50.)