Fiery_penguin_of_doom wrote...
ShaggyJebus wrote...
If we want to get everybody on the same page, then we need to find out what everybody wants, in detail. Do people want less hostility but the ability to still poke fun at one another? That might work, but it could lead to misunderstandings. So, do people want a good place to talk and would be willing to eliminate any kind of negative talk to gain such? I know a lot of people wouldn't want that.
To chip in to answer your question (ignoring the rest of this thread). What I personally want from Fakku is a place I can go to talk intelligently with my fellow Fakkuza. I want the community to have that "family" feeling like we're all brothers, sister, cousins,etc again. Family members can squabble and everything would still be cool like it used to. The problem is people aren't squabbling anymore over misunderstandings or whatever but, a certain group of users have a history of causing trouble. Just like the laws of the land. The laws of fakku should be impartial, unforgiving, uncaring. You break them, you lose, period. There is too much favoritism on the forums when it comes to the rules. I know other staff members have tried to correct this problem to no avail. So at this point, the only person who can do anything at this point is Jacob.
I also want the rules to be enforced for once. Someone flames a user or harasses a user then they should get punished. I don't give a fuck if they personally suck Jacob off every day. They are a user and are held to the same standards as every other user. The only exceptions are the mods who would be held to a slightly higher more "professional" standard. A perfect example for that "standard" is Gambler. I have never once had a reason to even entertain the thought of him doing anything unmod like.
Now, I'll leave this thread before I catch some sort of disease or something.
I completely agree as well.
However, this is Jacob's forum and he is free to run it the way he wants. If I don't like it, I am free to spend my time elsewhere. This is not to say I think Jacob has a "love it or leave it" attitude; I believe he cares a great deal about the Fakku community. That being said, so far, very little action(other than a threat of a rules crackdown that quickly aborted and never followed through) has occurred.
What I really want is to hear something from Jacob and the admins. Tell us how you see the situation, what you plan to do or not do, what the goal is for the forum and community. Us users have given our input concerning the forums, but what really matters with respect to tangible change is what you think, and that is why I want to know.
On the subject of rep . . .
Several ideas concerning "fixing" rep have been proposed and discussed(my only personal involvement in the suggestion process was concerning the elimination of negative rep), but most met with significant resistance. I have come to believe that there are significant entrenched interests who support the current rep system and want to keep it the way it is rather than change it. Jacob himself recognized this.
Jacob on 6/28/09 wrote...
I never intended reputation to be used as it is now. That doesn't mean I don't like it's current use, but it wasn't my original intent.
Originally I planned to use reputation as a way to give people permission to upload manga to the site and edit manga information. I assumed people with higher reputation could be trusted with those privileges. But obviously I never finished my plans and now it looks like that won't be happening.
I probably won't remove reputation just because I think it is a powerful system. The community is passionate about it (not always positively). And I don't think it's a bad thing when people get upset about losing reputation or feel happy when they receive one. I have come very close to removing reputation that goes below zero, meaning that no one can have negative reputation points. That is probably the closest I will come to removing it.
But I am open to hearing everyone's thoughts on the subject.