sifian_ wrote...
I suppose I can chime in with my pseudo-experience on this one.
Fall sophomore year, one girl seems to be the object of a lot of guys affections- not mine though. She forbade me from ever developing feelings for her. I laugh and say no problem.
A few months later a large group of friends were watching tv in a friend's room. 4 of us are on a queen size bed. Previously mentioned girl is getting really snuggly with me. I say to her, "It's funny we're together like this when you told me never to get get feelings for you." Her response was, "I wish I had never said that." I still wasn't all that interested in her, but opted to go with the flow. It's not often that a girl flat out says, "I want you!" and i had nothing against her.
Fall senior year, I've been dating the girl in question for nearly 2 years. My feelings for her are quite strong and we've said we'll be together forever (and we've been having sex for a while now.) She get's a love letter from one of our friends that we've know for all through high school, and takes it way too seriously. She's troubled by the dilemma because she has feeling for both of us.
My opinion was that she should just blow it off- she was already involved with me, and the two of them could deal with a little tension for the few months left in high school. Her thought was she wished we were in a matriarchal polygamous society so she needn't choose. After a few weeks of deliberation, she chose the other guy.
Worst Christmas ever.
After that, her relationship with the other guy was very short lived- like 2 months- my rebound girlfriend lasted longer than that, and only ended because I saw opportunity to get back with the original girl, which didn't pan out. Also, my relationship with the other guy was mended a whole lot faster than my relationship with her. He invited me to a barbecue like a year later and we were totally cool- he was just being true to himself, she was the one who had betrayed me. It wasn't until another two years after that (so like 3 years after the breakup) that I was able to forgive her, mostly because she has just given birth and I was really thankful it wasn't mine.
So where am I going with all this? I tried the traditional, "Make her choose the one she loves most" option, and it didn't work out well for anyone. I have some important memories from the ordeal, but they're probably fairly standard- not a whole lot more wisdom than I've gained since for other experiences. If I had the option to try again, I would go the extra-monogamous route. It probably wouldn't have worked out, but it would have been some serious experience that I doubt I'll have opportunity to get anywhere again... and I probably would have gotten to have sex with a few more times as well.
I remember a shirt stating the 'GOALS OF A BITCH' when i read this