Lelouch24 wrote...
Thomas Hobbs pretty much answers your question
Thomas Hobbs describes how man naturally behaves when there is no government & no enforcement of justice. He calls this environment a "state of nature", since man can behave naturally. In a state of nature, man becomes evil, and commits sin (I don't think he refered to the 7 deadly sins). There is no peace, no tranquility, no justice. Steal or be stolen from, kill or killed. Injustice is required to preserve our natural rights. Man desires to obtain peace, but in order to obtain peace, man must leave a their state of nature.
Man leaves a state of nature by creating government, and surrendering their natural rights to that government. This government then has the responsibillity to protect our natural rights. (Thomas Hobbs said that when a government fails to protect your natural rights, the citizens are f*cked and have to deal with it. John Locke had pretty much the same ideas as Hobbs, but Locke said we have a right to rebel when the government fails to protect our rights)
It's complicated to describe man's nature while under government, because it's when we aren't under government that our true nature is expressed
If it's in a man's state of nature to be anarchic, then why would he create a government? Clearly making a government is also apart of man's nature. I also have qualms with this only being a philosophers opinion. Bring out the experimental evidence instead because only then can the facts be revealed. It is an interesting question of what a group of people isolated from the rest of the world would do on their own. I think that most people have no reason to kill each other because it would be more beneficial to keep them around.
Here's an experiment of the mind and your own reactions: If you were stranded on an island with a group of people, would you kill them or work together? If you stole from them and they found out you'd realize it was a mistake because they won't help you anymore.
If we say we are animals, then we can see examples of nature where groups of animals work together, such as a pack of wolves, a dolphin school, etc.