RandomChoice wrote...
The United States doesn't have a police problem, because the United States doesn't have police. Cities and States have police inside the United States and counties can have a Sharif, but the United States doesn't have a police force in the traditional sense(Federal Police are things like custom agents). It is clear that there are police departments that need cleaning up, but police are local government agencies made to deal with local problems and should be addressed by the local population.
You can't look at police in isolation either, because the nature of a police department is determined by what crime occurs in the local area. Alaskan Police care a lot about hunting laws because that is a big thing in Alaska, but I don't think the Ferguson Police Department really cares about that at all. A bad police department is also a good sign that the local area has problems as well. That isn't an excuse for the police department, but police brutality is a symptom of a larger issue.
My problem with this rise in anti-police sentiment is that it is making a crisis out something that isn't. The local police where I live are doing a really good job and I don't feel they need to really change anything. I imagine most local police departs are like that as well, and problems they do have stem from the fact they may have officers who shouldn't be police. There are some departments that have deeper problems and those should be addressed, but that should be left to the local population who has to live there.
United States is indeed more alike to the European Union rather a normal country. But then, even in the EU, if something outrageous happens in one of it's countries, all the other countries react and also try to analyze if they share the same problem after all, as they are very similar culturally wise and in practical effects. So, even if it is just some police stations fault, it is still a country wise problem,
specially because it is happening in so many different states that you can't say it's just a single states' problem or a single police station's fault.
VillagersUnite wrote...
When it comes to rise in Police Brutality it is hard to answer. Some of the brutality cases that are showing up are seen as racist due to a white cop killing a black child. In all honesty I think cops are getting a little more trigger happy even though police brutality has been in this world for a long time. There is a such thing as criminal profiling and people can see it as racist but I think they are profiling people for a reason. Well some cops anyway. I can't really think of a solution for this issue because humans are a very hard headed race. People are going to do what they want whether they can get away with it or not.
You can say criminal profiling and fine, but then their profile is absolutely out from reality by a massive gap, a gap that is solely racisms' fault. Black people is the target of happy trigger by an absurd proportion. Even some police stations recognized they have racism problems in their institution and will try to amend it. It is something similar that happens here (Chile), police profiles low class people as various times more dangerous,
even when we have more violent crimes recorded (%) coming from high class pals: that is a obvious case of classicism (fueled by ignorance like any arbitrary discrimination).
That does not mean that everyone are racist or that there exist an organized hate like a new Ku Klux Klan in the police. But that does mean that there still exist hardcore racists in the U.S (even if are few) and than subconscious racism is still common. Something must be done to the respect to eliminate it for once for all, specially from institutions. Now that does not change the fact that police is happy triggering too much, but it is a hard problem to solve as sometimes the happy triggers indeed saves their life (it is absurd than even a kid can shoot you back, but that is the U.S' reality). It can be reduced by people's protest, but I don't know how much you can reduce happy triggering before actually starting to lose more cops there, though we will know for sure more soon than later for good with all those protests.