Damienthedevil wrote...
Well....1st things 1st.....
Good Parts
1)The focus of your story was good and it was quite fresh. As long as the story doesn't get too complicated it should develope nicely.
2)The characters were describe very simply and therefore easier to imagine. Though i think that it would be better to be original...
Bad Parts
1)Plot - I did say that the focus of your story was good but i think that the way it developed right now is.....boring to be frank.....You focused too little on the setting and not only did you not describe it properly you didn't even put out a baseline/general image for your story...I'm guessing you are just going to develope it how you see fit and didn't give a thought about how it should go right? Please think out your story 1st before posting anymore it was too sloppily done.
2)Characters - Ugh.... The characters i believe you based them of the anime characters you watched right..... really bad idea.... You just practically copied them off..... The names as well.... it didn't even suit them....i mean come on!!! Saito?! you just copied them off Zero no Tsukaima... You should think about how the name would suit each character. Then you should think about their personalities and details like that before you decide. Don't just decide on the spot like that. By the way, in the prologue with the bandits you should have let "Saito" kill them instead of just knocking them out. You just made him seem like a softie instead of a killer.....
3)Originality - You had almost no original concepts here unless you count the "Four Demons" Those guys are messed up in the 1st place.... WTH man..."Even the Akatsuki fears them" WHAT THE F***!!!!! The Akatsuki fears no one.... They are the strongest organization in Naruto...HOW IN THE NAME OF HELL would they even fear some random nobody... You should have at least put them on par with Akatsuki, perhaps like "They have the same amount of influence/battle power with Akatsuki" wouldn't that sound better? it gives more sense see..... AND!!! try to think up names on your own, you are getting too much reference from Naruto that it almost seem like plagirism....
Overall 5.0/10.0 seriously try better than this.... Nothing in this story strikes me as good....Even Uzumaki 101's and Leed's storyline+developement was better than this
Ok, Here's the deal.
1.Chracters: I'm not really familiar with Japanese names. I've never seen Zero no Tsukaima. I don't really know how I came up with the name Saito it just kinda came to me randomly. As far as copying other characters from the series, I'm not. I'm working on getting a scanner so I can post some pics of these characters. And the bandits, He didn't kill them because he didn't need to. Later on he does in a rather violent manner.
2. Plot: As far as the setting goes, I haven't gotten very far into the series, so I'm trying to describe places I have no reference for. As for the story goes, yeah, it's a little boring now, but, that's because it's still in the beginning.
3. Originality: The four demons, the idea here is these are four highly skilled assassins. And if you go back and read the passage it said "not even the Akatsuki touch them" and when I said they feared them the coment was made by someone who doesn't really know what he's talking about, Kazuma is supposed to be a dumbass. It's more like these guys don't officially exist. Most people wouldn't have heard of them, because they generally prefer to lurk in the shadows. Your suggestion is basically the point I was trying to get across.
I appreciate your critique. This is what I'm looking for to improve apon my writing ability. It's one of those things where, in my head I've got it worked out, but then I type it up I have problems, currently I'm deciding exactly what I'm gonna do for chapter 3. Maybe make a few changes to the other chapters. Once I get a scanner I'll post pics of the characters, and I feel confident in saying they are NOT ripoffs. However, as far as the names go, if you have any suggestions lemme know, I'm pretty shitty at naming my characters except for the demons I draw (I can make up whatever sounds good). As far as these characters go I can only really go off of names I've heard in anime.Either way +rep, thx for the feedback.