Like you said, it's probably a matter of tastes that I didn't get too much mileage out of this in terms of laughs.
I would argue that the supernatural is quite prominent in this entry unless you don't consider humanoids with slimy skins and tendrils for hair as supernatural beings. I think the way the monsters reproduce is very unpleasant and unsettling. It can be considered horror. The supernatural and horror themes play a major role in this story surely! Without those, how can I come up with the twist that those women are really monsters that seduce men?
Glad you thought it is mystery even though I think this entry does the job of coming up with a mystery plot poorly compared to the other two themes. There is intentionally no resolution because I insist on doing a bizarre twist and more importantly because it is difficult to wrap up.
I can only conclude that the reason why you didn't rate this piece highly is only because it is an attempt at comedy. That said, I insist in incorporating humour whatever the themes are. There are too few comedic pieces. Most of the comedy in the forum are unintentionally or otherwise in the Incoherent Babbling section.
There are definitely elements of supernatural and horror in there. I just don't think they play that integral of a role to the entry. As for me not rating it highly because of it being an attempt at comedy, I will say that I've seen Zombieland and am 3 episodes into Ash vs Evil Dead, both of which are comedy horrors, and I think they're freaking awesome. This entry just didn't strike me as all that funny like I've already said.
Care to go into detail?
Can't really say too much here. Jokes either make me laugh or they don't. I know what makes me laugh, but I don't think I could tell you why.
You find a story about someone reading a second hand account of men complaining about loose and vindictive women behaving badly after a trip to a club, who proceeds to read another account accusing the women to be monstrous demons, only to find out that the truth is a bit of both not crazy or outrageous enough?! I shudder to think what you consider crazy!
I think the problem I have is I can tell from the first few paragraphs and knowing your writing style that you're going to throw some crazy interviews at me so I built up this expectation in my head, and what I got wasn't that.
Perhaps it is something high_time would write.
You're giving me flashbacks and not the good kind.
My attempts at humouring you are about as successful as your attempts at humouring me.
Maybe someday we'll come up with something the other really likes. Maybe.
Out of curiosity, why wasn't there an honourable mention? Was it because the number of entries were too few?
I think that's already been answered in the winners topic? Can't remember. Basically, yeah, too few entries.