Well, he’s definitely impregnated two girls even if they don’t realize it. The church probably keeps it a secret to prevent over population or for a ridiculous reason like it’s a cardinal sin. Hopefully they figure this out sooner than later.
Looks like our protagonist is going to get himself another addition to his growing harem and I think its going to be a case of "Hey Mikey, I think she likes it." when she gets the him to herself.