****excuse my grammar/spelling, i suck at it***
I really dilly and batililly liked this one.
I was able to picture the whole story in my head with ease and the story itself was well written. Although the story itself was pretty predictable, the background story of Jason and Rose show'd that they were no ordinary bandit's. I also liked the part's where you introduce'd the gate guard into the story and gave him the appropriate personality. Karne played the role of a sucker who fell for the trap well. I really liked how you gave that snobby military characteristic to Inquisitor Zarkazon. He play'd his part with perfection at the Gate scene really well.
Overall, it was definitely really good story but I would have wished for an alternative ending. An ending where Jason has already gone through Death itself and knew how lonely and dark it was. Experiencing that alone made him wish for Rose to live long and well so that she wouldn't have to go through was he has gone through. He might have also believe'd that if he was to ever die again, that Rose might be able to revive him back from the dead just as before. Then he think of a plan to convince that if they were to ever be caught in a tight situation, that he would like for her to live on, and he will probably have to feed her some bs on how she could revive him back to life if something was to ever happen, so she wont back out of the plan. Then when it comes to the part where they are caught in the alley, Jason whisper to Rose that he's going to make an opening to help her escape. She manage's to escape while he try's to take out as many as he can until he ends up being killed by a lucky stab from Inquisitor Zarkazon. End it there and make the reader wanting to crave for more. I know that If i was in Jason shoe's, that what I would have done.
Ohh boy, but I must say, you gave Rose a wonderful name. When you think hard about her name, you will soon realize that it fits in perfect with the story. It so perfect that you can even take out the part where her parents gave her that name but instead replace it to show that she had another name but the Malteer Empire gave her that nickname based on her background. Why is it perfect? Well, when you think about a pretty lady that has proper manners, and is kind to all, you think of an innocent lady and when you think about a rose, you either see it as way of showing life or death, also a Rose has thorns on them. As a lady bandit, she's the type of gal that deceives people with her innocence (Innocent part of her name), but she can also take your life if she wanted to(A rose of death), but in her case, she was able to bring her partner back to life(A rose of life), which leads to her name as Innocent Rose. So when commoners think of a bandit called "Innocent Rose", they will think of a Rose that may seem innocent by it's natural beauty but can easily cut you with it's sharp thorns. So the name reminded to watch out for any innocent lady's, as she can take your life away if you get caught in her trap..... Exactly as how that man on that wagon died. Saw a pretty young lady come out from the creepy forest, fell for her trap, and payed the price of death.
Ahh, but ya, no need to listen to me about changing it, my fantasy's are running wild on this story right now.
But ya i liked it, good job.
There was only two sentence's that didn't sound right to me
This didn't sound right. You can probably word it better.
“It’s just down the main road, big sign out front. You can’t miss it."
Specifically this part
"Big sign out front"
Second is this. It left me confused.
Rose cursed the halfwit excuses for parents the gods had graced her with.
Didn't like how this sounded also.
Could they have come up with a dumber name?
I feel like it would of been better if you said
"Couldn't they have came up with a better name?"
d(^_^)(^_^)d wrote...
The first little scene with the arrow is a result of me going OCD and wanting to cover as many logical gaps as I could. After writing the scene where Rose stops Karne so Jason can sneak up behind and kill him, I realized they could have just used arrows without having to go through the trouble of creating the ruse they used. So I thought to myself, "I must include something that explains why they won't be using arrows!" Not that that counters your point at all. I just wanted to share.
Why didn't you explain as to who killed Karne in the story. I picture'd it as Rose killing Karne with a dagger right in the back while he was lifting her, and then Jason showing up seconds later already looking inside the Wagon.
Meh, i'm no writer as you can see, so don't overkill me.