Manga and Doujinshi
0
I see one problem. On the "Doujinshi -> Sort by Series" page I see series only up to "Dynasty Warriors". The rest is cut off, and there is no button to change pages or something. Is something wrong for me, or is it a common problem?
0
Ehhh... Just one thing... WHERE IS MY DOWNLOAD BUTTON?! (keep calm... keep calm... breathe in... breathe out... in... out...)
0
leonard267
FAKKU Non-Writer
Not only are the download links are missing, I can't find the list of the artists whose names begin with 'B' onwards. I do hope something can be done about that.
0
I like the idea, it makes more sence to divide it up so much since there's so much here, not that I'm complaining!
0
Thanks for the update. I've actually wished there was something like this before and I'm glad it did happen. Differentiating manga from doujinshi is important too as many people get confused.
https://www.fakku.net/viewtopic.php?p=3100690
It's in the 2nd page of this thread, please read other comments first before posting since your queries may have already been answered.
owning09 wrote...
can i ask where is the f-ing download button!!!!???https://www.fakku.net/viewtopic.php?p=3100690
It's in the 2nd page of this thread, please read other comments first before posting since your queries may have already been answered.
0
chaosbreak wrote...
!!walw6pK4Alo wrote...
OddlyMad wrote...
In essence a [Manga] a serialized graphic comic, and a [Doujinshi] Is a graphic comic based or sprung off from an {manga/anime] that is already serialized, right? o.oNo. You can have completely original characters and stories in doujinshi, or have established characters and stories in normal manga. Like Black Lilith often commissions manga adaptations of their games that are published professionally in hentai magazines. The difference here is the professional aspect, whether or not they're being paid and printed officially. Doujinshi are fanmade, fan printed, and fan distributed.
^this
basically, what jacob said isnt completely true
Original Hentai = Manga section
Doujinshi Hentai = Doujinshi section
There, clear as water.
0
Great work sir! Now I can have the pleasure of looking for manga, doujinshi AND search multi tag! FAKKU FOR LIFE!!!
0
I've been receiving herp derp errors for some time and the server capacity is in heavy load thingy? What's happening?
0
I do think there were good changes made and I thank you for that.
However, I believe there could have been more direct changes that could have been implemented that extend beyond what had been done. For instance, segregating manga and doujinshi is a good feature. However, the segregation is ultimately going to be 'skin deep' rather than the more definitive segregation that more direct 'original manga' works here on Fakku really need.
What I mean for example, is that Velvet Kiss and An Angel's Marshmallow for instance, should really not be placed into the same realm as many of the one-shot works that exist on Fakku, like Barrier Free (one of my favorites). If there continues to remain a broad 'original manga' tag line, it needs to be even further segregated to place original manga works that sustain under more lengthy serialization apart from those that only received a single issue or one-shot from their author(s). Having the ability to search across tags and such is good, but I think that there still remains a rather broad definition of how the uploads are segregated - and that will just become an issue further along the line as more content is added.
Another thing that still and will likely continue to be an issue is there really needs to be a more definitive definition on the actual difference between 'manga' and 'doujinshi'. There is a difference - even if one doesn't understand it fully. Doujinshi is a fan-created work based off of an existing work, while simple 'manga' as it is defined here is an original work created by a particular artist. Both are manga in the manga-est sense of terms, but there is a definitive line as to how one should apply each term.
This then requires a more intricate review of the material that already exists here and to that material that will eventually see upload here. For instance, Corpse Party Museum is still listed as 'original work', which drops it into the 'manga' category. Yet, Corpse Party Museum is **technically** a doujinshi, since it's based off of a game made using RPGMaker which came first. This relegates any subsequent works as doujin. However, further confusion could exist in that if I remember right the Corpse Party Museum work that is currently on Fakku is the original and official 'manga' for the series.
And extending even beyond that, some comments were made above that professional artists whom do the original drawing of their manga cannot create doujin. This is untrue. Satoshi Urushihara has done many doujin works of stuff he has done character designs for, such as Growlanser. If you have ever read the Growlanser novels, you will also see Urushihara's work in these issues, but since these novels are the official work for the games they are technically *not* doujin. Only subsequent work Urushihara does - and has done - outside the official realm of what is published for the series is considered doujin. Peach Pit is another example of an artist group that doujin'ed their own works, having themselves started out as a doujin group. There is also many more examples of the above that I could ramble about for some time.
However, I believe there could have been more direct changes that could have been implemented that extend beyond what had been done. For instance, segregating manga and doujinshi is a good feature. However, the segregation is ultimately going to be 'skin deep' rather than the more definitive segregation that more direct 'original manga' works here on Fakku really need.
What I mean for example, is that Velvet Kiss and An Angel's Marshmallow for instance, should really not be placed into the same realm as many of the one-shot works that exist on Fakku, like Barrier Free (one of my favorites). If there continues to remain a broad 'original manga' tag line, it needs to be even further segregated to place original manga works that sustain under more lengthy serialization apart from those that only received a single issue or one-shot from their author(s). Having the ability to search across tags and such is good, but I think that there still remains a rather broad definition of how the uploads are segregated - and that will just become an issue further along the line as more content is added.
Another thing that still and will likely continue to be an issue is there really needs to be a more definitive definition on the actual difference between 'manga' and 'doujinshi'. There is a difference - even if one doesn't understand it fully. Doujinshi is a fan-created work based off of an existing work, while simple 'manga' as it is defined here is an original work created by a particular artist. Both are manga in the manga-est sense of terms, but there is a definitive line as to how one should apply each term.
This then requires a more intricate review of the material that already exists here and to that material that will eventually see upload here. For instance, Corpse Party Museum is still listed as 'original work', which drops it into the 'manga' category. Yet, Corpse Party Museum is **technically** a doujinshi, since it's based off of a game made using RPGMaker which came first. This relegates any subsequent works as doujin. However, further confusion could exist in that if I remember right the Corpse Party Museum work that is currently on Fakku is the original and official 'manga' for the series.
And extending even beyond that, some comments were made above that professional artists whom do the original drawing of their manga cannot create doujin. This is untrue. Satoshi Urushihara has done many doujin works of stuff he has done character designs for, such as Growlanser. If you have ever read the Growlanser novels, you will also see Urushihara's work in these issues, but since these novels are the official work for the games they are technically *not* doujin. Only subsequent work Urushihara does - and has done - outside the official realm of what is published for the series is considered doujin. Peach Pit is another example of an artist group that doujin'ed their own works, having themselves started out as a doujin group. There is also many more examples of the above that I could ramble about for some time.
