Gunma VS Yamatogawa: Who does it better?

Um, isn't Gunma guilty of that as well on occasion? (Hello, Mai Favorite!) Also, not all of Yamatogawa's work is like that. Aqua Bless has only two stories involving more than two people. Without actually going so far as to compiles statistics, both of them seem to share equal amounts of 1-on-1s, threesomes, and orgies.

Anyway, I chose Yamatogawa. There is just simply more diversity in his characters compared to Gunma. If you were to throw in all of Gunma's original characters, both female and male, I wouldn't be able to determine which series they are from. In Yamatogawa's case, I can tell the females apart, and I might be able to tell the males apart. Additionally, I find myself liking Yamatogawa's female proportions better, particularly with the breasts. Even though I have a breast fetish, I can only handle so much of Gunma's bipolar pillowy/DFC breasts.

Definitely Yamatogawa. I feel that the characters and their expressions are way more erotic and sensual. His artwork is more varied and vivid. And his stories are a bit more romantic and dramatic. I love Midori from Tayu Tayu, her feelings are expressed genuinely.

As for Gunma's work, the characters are often indistinguishable, and the stories don't draw me in. The occasional old man is a major turn-off too. But his art is still better than most. To each his own, I guess.

Wow this is a tough decision. Awesome idea for a thread udou_akira.

Gunma has been a long time favorite of mine. When I first started reading his works the artwork blew me away.

But these days Yamatogawa is quickly becoming my favorite. I own the Aqua Bless book, this is one of the chapters:
https://www.fakku.net/viewmanga.php?id=2485

Gunma used to be my favourite but as a few users before have stated characters tend to become indistinguishable from one series to the other.
I have to go with Yamatogawa on this one.
He did the Tayu Tayu series in a way that made my mind blow (and some other things). Both Fapping-wise and Storywise Yamatogawa takes the cake for me.

Tough tough decision... but I ended up going with Yamatogawa. Here's why:

Gunma Kisaragi:
better artwork
better sex scenes

Yamatogawa:
better story plot
better character development
better character distinguishing

So, Yamatogawa has the one up against Gunma Kisaragi in my opinion, but this is one epic battle I say, something I was surprised that anyone would come up with this sort of idea. +rep udou_akira.

[size=11]I have a soft copy ^^ [/h]

so does doujinland lol

[size=11]And so does everyone.[/h]

Yamatogawa. I also went out and purchased a copy of Aqua Bless, and also plan on buying Witchcraft when it makes its way onto the market.

huuh witchcraft is draw by yamatogawa? that is one of my favorite too.

meh, didn't think it was that great...perfer witchraft and tayu tayu

edited post...

Gunma for me. d(^__^)b

yea i agree with you there....not really into funtanari (i think that's how it's spelled but im not sure lol)

there was one fate stay night doujin that was futanari and it's here on fakku....forgot the name but i liked that one

ooh, dead tie 50/50 lol

damn this is tough ... uhhh im gonna go with Yamatogawa

I went with Yamatogawa, but both are amazing. I just like Yamatogawa's style a little more.

Gunma for me. He's not my favorite artist, his work is more artistically beautiful than arousing for me, but I don't thin Yamatogawa is all that great, in storytelling or art.

I'm perhaps not all that fond of either one here, but went with Yamatogawa. Simply because aside from the ridiculously large cocks, I like his art a great deal, and from time to time he cobbles together a nice little story as well.

Both.