Gunma VS Yamatogawa: Who does it better?

Gunma Kisaragi is doing hell of a job!!!

Gunma is a little better. . .
But, I like both of them

Both great artists but for me Gunma comes out on top. When I first read "A Newlywed's Life" I just couldn't get enough of it lol. Even to this day it's still one of my favorites from Gunma.

Hmm, one of the very, very rare doujins that I read where the girl is already in a relationship with another man, be it boyfriend or husband, and I felt no guilt fapping to it. This one, and Kigurumi panic to name another example.

Its all great fapping material and I found that "Kigurumi Panic" doujin to be more funny than anything else lol.

I liked the fellatio in that one. Also, when she bent over and he saw her pussy and he had a series of flashbacks of all the times where he greeted her, thinking only of how he wished he could have her, and now the pussy he so wanted was there, in front of him and spread open. That, was beautiful.

For storylines and concept, I like Gunma. For artwork, I prefer Yamatogawa. But overall, since I'm more of a storyline man, I vote for Kisaragi Gunma! :D

Yeah and it seemed like the guy just cracked into some kind of pussy fucking frenzy.

According to the Front Page Polls, Gunma pulled ahead by 478 votes out of 6250 voters, an 8% difference - fucking close.

Stats from poll:
54% Gunma [ 3364 Votes ]
46% Yamatogawa [ 2886 Votes ]

I admit this was an awesome debate, but I think the romance in Yamatogawa's works pulls me in more.

Yeah I was wondering where that original poll went lol, but anyways yeah I can understand when people say that Yamatogawa puts more of a personality into his girls and more into the romance of the doujin and making a good story to go with it. But idk for me there's just something about Gunma's work that pulls me in like his sex scenes being really hot or how his artwork is very clean. Although I like Yamatogawa's work as well also how it can be more realistic its just I find his artwork slightly unappealing, but thats just me take it however you want.

I'll fap to either artist's work. They both rock! XD
it's just that gunma sometimes makes really disgusting stories where the girl's get raped or have sex with old farts. Boner loss right there.

Really? Haven't seen any of those, I've only seen the ones that have been shown on Fakku and please don't give me any examples of those either lol. As for Yamatogawa I'm not sure if I'm right, but wasn't Gunma making doujins long before Yamatogawa did? The guy probably hasn't had a chance to expand his doujins to different kinds of fetishes, I don't know.

You've obviously haven't seen all of Gunma's release then. The ones I'm reffering to with the old farts are all here, so keep that in mind when you decide to read the ones you haven't read yet...

Are you sure? I did a search in the search bar above the Fakku banner for any doujin relating to Kisaragi Gunma and the only one that I found relating to what you said was "In The Nurse's Room". Unless what your saying is also including the Mai Favorite series, then there are some but not that much.

That one, love selection chapter 5, you see one of the girl's sucking off the boss before having sex with the main character. Mai favorite had old geezers now and then. Love selection chapter 6 has a girl getting gangraped in the train by old people and of course, she eventually loves it. I think there were more but I can think of any...for now. Oh right, love selection chapter 7 and it's sequel. So you see, there are a few.

Ok lets see in love selection chapter 5 she's sucking off the main character's friend not some old geezer. And for love selection chapter 6 there was only one old guy in that gang rape. And as for love selection chapter 7 I don't think I've seen it same for it's sequel. But I do understand your point about there being some old guys in there, but it wasn't as many and as bad as you had made me think it was. It would basically have to be like YAKIYAMA LINE for me to think otherwise.

Perhaps, but Raisin bread=PURE, EPIC WIN

Lol no disagreement here.

Omg i can't choose...and the poll is deadlocked at the moment with 28 votes each.