must_kill_moe_weee wrote...
The paper quality for Cute Devil Girlfriend and Deep Stalker isn't the same as the 2nd edition of Yamatogawa books? well that's disappointing...
Unfortunately,
Cute Devil Girlfriend 2nd Ed. and
Deep Stalker are at least a couple steps below, maybe more, in terms of paper stock than the 2nd Ed. Yamatogawa ones. They have that grittier feel to the pages and have the light grayish white tone instead of a pure white tone like you see with the 2nd Ed. Yamatogawa books or FAKKU books. They are not bad by any means, they are just not the higher quality smooth white paper. Comparing them with some of my non ero manga, I find they are slightly better than the paper stock used for
Haganai, released by Dark Horse, and are close to
Food Wars, released by Viz.
Strange Sex in Parallel Worlds has a mostly smooth white paper stock, though it is just a step down from the 2nd Ed. Yamatogawa books. Probably one option below the one used for them while the other two are at least two options below if not three or four, but still on par with or slightly better than most regular manga releases in the US.
must_kill_moe_weee wrote...
As for the 2nd edition of Yamatogawa books, I have Boing Boing and Witchcraft and I gotta say sure it's not high quality as FAKKU books but I think I'm pretty satisfied with the quality of it. If only Project-H would just release all their books in that kind of quality I wouldn't mind spending 20 bucks per book but I'm still hesitant on buying from them again. Of course, as a completionist I do intend to buy more books but I'm still going to have issues with their pricing.
Agreed. They should make the paper stock used with the 2nd Ed. Yamatogawa books the standard going forward. Though, I'm not gonna hold my breath there. However, I don't think they are using that paper stock on any of their other releases as of now. Maybe they are on the most recent stuff from the past month or two, but even
Strange Sex in Parallel Worlds was just a tad lower paper quality, though still pretty good and mostly smooth and white. If they at least use the paper stock from
Strange Sex in Parallel Worlds, then I'd consider that a win as it would at least be fairly smooth and white paper instead of the more newsprint kind.
must_kill_moe_weee wrote...
I don't really care too much about the paper quality but I think their 2nd edition of Yamatogawa books are perfectly good enough. If they can't compete with the paper quality department with FAKKU, that's fine with me but they should at least set the standard for their new books in the same quality as the 2nd edition of Yamatogawa books. It really irritates me I have to pay nearly 20 bucks for an older book which has newspaper like paper quality (which I'm trying to finish Ring X mama and Velvet Kiss).
Unfortunately, I think they have their mind made up to stay the course for those older titles with the cheaper paper stock. I do have hope the newer stuff will be done on the mostly smooth and white paper in
SSiPW. I'm not sure they are willing to spring for the 2nd Ed. Yamatogawa paper on every new release yet, since that seems to be done moreso due to having the KS funds in place, but we'll see. Honestly, if they just priced the books with cheaper paper cheaper, they would at least be setting their value in a more fair range. For the paper they used with
CDG and
DS, they should probably be priced closer to $15, but I digress.
must_kill_moe_weee wrote...
I know both FAKKU and Project-H are doing their own thing and I really don't like to make comparisons in which one is better than the other because I really appreciate the fact that we're even getting hentai translated and uncensored but in terms of bang for buck I just gotta go with FAKKU. As for Project-H, I have my frustrations with them but I'm glad we're at least getting Yamatogawa and Mizuryu kei books and some really hardcore titles, so I'm at least glad we're getting that much.
Yeah, putting in perspective the state of the ero manga scene in the US before FAKKU went legit with its books, things were shrinking rapidly and we were lucky to even get licenses from Project-H. I, too, am glad we are at least getting anything legally from them, especially the work from those two. That said, cheaping out on the release almost becomes a self fulfilling prophecy, as you think you can't afford to do a quality job because you need to be cautious but then you in turn disappoint the fans who buy for the quality. Hopefully FAKKU's success and the Kickstarter's success has shown them the market is still there if you have a quality product and they continue to make improvements from here on out.
Overall, I'm pleased with my order but feel the value for the money is just not quite up to my expectations when I know it can, and should, be done better. I will still buy stuff from artists I like but I'm a lot more cautious with buying anything on the spur of the moment before knowing details about the quality of the release.
I've got two more books from Project-H coming next week from Amazon, had a gift card to use so they are free for me, and will post about their quality here then as well so others will know. They are the standard edition of
Vanilla Essence and
Ane Kyun: My Sweet Sweet Elder Sister.