Chuu !! wrote...
g-money wrote...
And like you said before, newtype abilities are evolved. It wasn't until after Gundam SEED and well into SEED Destiny that he begins to show abilities akin to newtypes. You're telling me that Kira can sense lacus's danger all the way from planetside? And no, the earliest Gundam series I've ever watched was Z Gundam... and I'll admit that series bored me too. Kamille gets his mind scrambled in the end? What kind of ending is that?
I also throw that question right back at you: what is Gundam? Is it an animation series, a type of mecha, or something that you're making it not to be? You wanna talk about origins? Gundams were created to be advanced warmachines to turn the tide of war - no more, no less. Your last statement reminds me of Gundam 00, where Gundam symbolizes war, power, and freedom, paradoxically. And Gundam SEED isn't my favorite show; G Gundam is. I don't need other series' backgrounds to influence me when I'm watching other Gundam series - I take what it is and keep my expectations low unless it's a sequel of sorts.
Chuu!!, I've carefully coated my words and arguments in neutral terms, but if you want to make this into a sort of grudge match, I will not oblige. And if you want to argue, please polish your english skills and stop making assumptions about a person you don't know because that's rude. I don't hate the UC series, but I don't think you can appreciate the CE series either.
ok. sorry for my bad english.
you cant judge Z Gundam if you say the ending was bad. do you watch ZZ Gundam? Kamille at last regain his consciousness and he's united with Fa Yuiry (sorry if i spoil. but you ask for it). what do you think? is that all happy ending you want? every story has it's own ending. and it's Tomino-sensei who decided it all. you cannot say it's bad. see what gundam pros in mahq.net says.
http://mahq.net/animation/gundam/gundam.htm
it's a prove. that even you are a Gundam pilot,or even you are a Newtype,you still cannot always gain a Happy Ending. remember what happens with Four Murasame,right? that's the prove that Gundam is EVIL
Gundam is not a machine to turn the tides of war. it's a symbol of HATRED from each other. EF making Gundam in hope that they're can finished the war. what happens then? the war cannot be stop. as long as there's Gundam,there's no peace. Zeon also mark Gundam as their symbol of Hatred towards EF and earthlings. that's why they wont PRODUCE gundam. instead,they're STEAL it. do you know what happens to gundam blue destiny? the true ending is,nobody survives.. even Nimbus is dead. Gundam can destroy EVERYTHING. earth,Zeon Fleet,innocent civilian,all can be destroyed. Gundam created in hopes to end the One Year War. the One Year War has ended,EF is win. but instead? what happen? more rebellious Group comes. Titan has arise,Neo Zeon arised back,the remaining Zeon Soldier tried to revenge,Crossbone Vanguard appears,Jupiter Fleet at last declares their war against EF,the rebirth of Zanscare Empire,OZ is forming their force to take control Earth once again,then comes White Fang.
you say you dont needs to see previous background. that means you're only enjoying a SPECIFIC gundam. not a Truly Gundam FANS. you're only enjoying G Gundam and Gundam SEED. besides,i call it sucks (no offense) because it really DOESNT have any connection to the PREVIOUS story. we dont know what happens in Usso Evin after V Gundam,what's his future,did he go against another force,it's all subtituted by G Gundam which seems so weird. because WTF is gundam can be a Super Robot? (once again,no offense)
Well, I never said the series was bad, just that I hated the Z Gundam ending, and I was so bored with ZZ Gundam that I gave it up, which is very unusual for me, even for a Gundam series.
Now as for your second argument, the symbology of Gundam becomes something more than just evil. HOWEVER, it was never meant to be a symbol of anything in the first place. It was originally meant to provide a means to end a war. Gundam had many advantages:
1. It can fight in space and had its own sealed compartment.
2. It has mobility unparalled to any other type of fighting unit out there.
3. It can be transformed for many uses: space, air, land, sea.
4. The technology of gundams are also far more advanced than the EF could anticipate, hence the creation of the first MS, dubbed "gundam".
I can only agree with part of your argument, especially when it's newtypes that create the chaos around them. I'll have to be honest; as long as it was some kind of new military unit, than that would become the source of hate, whether it was gundam or not. But putting that aside, it was never explicitly stated in the series that gundams represent hatred. Moreover, it's the people that use them bring out their hatred out onto the battlefield. I watched Z Gundam, V Gundam, and Gundam X, and the term newtype carries a far more deeper term than "gundam" itself.
But I digress. Gundam was never meant to be a symbol of anything. However, as wars grew on, it did begin take on a meaning. Rather than evil, gundams represented "power", power to take on the world, power to represent your ideals, power to gain freedom from oppression, power to end suffering. Zeon stealing gundams because it represented evil? Wtf? No sir, they stole gundams to have power that they didn't have. The TITANs? They used gundams to subjugate people - yet another form of a misabuse of power. The TITANs were associated with evil, not the gundams they piloted themselves. Look at Gundam 00 - the meaning of gundam was talked about in series... and the main character Setsuna likened gundam to a god of sorts, able to bring punishment and judgment on those he saw fit. And what does God represent? All knowing wisdom (technology), all encompassing sight (mobility), and all ominpotent power (power's power).
And look at the gundam series track record; what starts out as a fight for a greater cause eventually turns into a war of attrition, chaos, and personal vendettas, and the ultimate goal of peace. I haven't yet seen a gundam series that follows the aforementioned format. Z Gundam, G Gundam, V Gundam, Gundam X, Turn A Gundam, Wing Gundam, Gundam SEED, Gundam SEED Destiny, Gundam 00 - they all more or less follow a war-that's-turned-into-chaos-and-personal-vendetta format. And in reality, it's the humans that embody evil or good, and through gundams they express it. Gundam itself can be likened to a gun, and depending on WHO uses it, it can be used for good or bad. Gundam does not represent evil, rather it represents the power to do either good or evil, a vessel of sorts.
Now as for your last argument, I don't understand how I can watch a series for a specific gundam - you don't watch anime for just its characters because it's the plot that ultimately drives a series forward. Why should I care if a series has a sequel or not? Your way of talking and arguing proves that you're only a UC fan who can't accept the other gundam variations out there - you've even said it yourself. This makes arguing near pointless. Granted, I know that I'm not a UC fan, but I do appreciate Gundam's origins and especially Turn A Gundam and Gundam 08th MS Team. Gundam X gave a pretty interesting breakdown on the meaning of "newtype" and I thought V Gundam was one of the most gruesome shows ever televised because everyone around Usso kept dying. (and that blonde traitorous bitch who's name I've forgotten.)