SupremeSilver wrote...
When I refer to Jpop I am usually referring to Band,Rap,Electro,and Rock. I didn't say liking anime means you like Jpop, I just mention it as a tendency.
Your "I don't find too many black folk listening to "Pon Pon Pon". Most give me weird looks." very heavily implies it.
If your refering to "Band,Rap,Electro,and Rock." then your in luck, a lot of African-American's listen to those genre's.
SupremeSilver wrote...
So in your book crimes and having low to no income doesn't effect your ability to watch anime/manga at all? So if you were making less than 15k a year and have to live in a crime-infested neighborhood and live a hour away from your job, it wouldn't make the slightest difference in your ability to watch anime? If you already doing it or have done it before then kudos to you, if not your words don't have much weight. Also, you do realize that the internet and computer aren't free right? The cost of the internet can vary greatly depending on the ISP and location. Some people have to pay over a hundred dollars for internet and that's with limited bandwidth. If you get your computer stolen, which the warranty expired, how are you going to watch anime then? Watch it on tv? My statements do apply to youths since
the internet or computers aren't free,usually. Note that when I refer to black people I speaking in generalizations and as such my statements don't to apply every black person and vary on accuracy depending on location and the individual.
Personal experience is not equivalent to a collective, Rather "I" personally have or have not does not validate or invalidate my proposition. My experiences do not define the whole.
You've never heard of a library's, school computer labs, or free net for low income families through both cable/internet company and government based subsidies. Or heck, even DSL... For a time, a online school a relative of mine was going to, supplied him with both the computer and the funds for internet. Was a home schooling program funded through tax payers, pretty much a "public home school"... yadayadayada~ moving on...
People don't normally get their computers stolen... Most computers are not meant to be carried around. Warranties last 1-2 years, and most computers last 4-5. Fringe/extreme examples that have little to nothing to do with my statement, and can easily be thrown at any race.
Anyone who can afford a cellphone can afford a computer, they are computers at this point. Also, there are cellphone company and government subsidies for these too. The quality of the phone, I'm not entirely sure though...
The problem about generalizing, especially a group of people who live in a huge variety of living, economical, and locational differences, all on the same standard... is that it's stupid, plain and simple. What your doing is quantitatively no different than me stating "Most White Americans in the south live in mobile homes and are racist", "Most French men are rapist", "Most Africans are children soldiers/blood diamond miners", "Most Middle-Eastern's are terrorist", "Most Japanese are suicidal", "Most Chinese will kill or sell their daughter in a second"... I think you get the point... I hope. Your generalizing a whole group of people based off poorly contrived and obscured stereotypes. Generalizing is never anything you want to "boast".
Not that their is not inequality, or that blacks are not on a unfair scale in the economical and social world, because they are. But your generalization does not address anything to this regard, outside of stereotypes. It does not actually account for individual or collective circumstances beyond "their all dirt poor and can't afford shit", and yet you claim vigorously, how logical your statements are.
SupremeSilver wrote...
Again, I didn't say liking anime equates to knowing some words in Japanese, I mention it as a tendency especially if claim to watch a lot of anime since the vast majority of animes don't have English dubs and Baka is used quite often.
Ya sorry, I wrote "liking" instead of "watching", my mistake, but if you want to say you didn't say that... "I remember calling some black guy
who claims he watch alot of anime a "Baka" and he had no idea what I telling him...Good Day..."
Numbers... Say their is 10,000 series of anime/manga.. (to small, I kno, tis example, and I should probably count games too).
3,000 of them make it to the states.
Majority doesn't make it here, but a substantial amount does.
Enough exist in an English format for an "American otaku" to invest an equal amount in comparison to a "Japanese otaku".
SupremeSilver wrote...
Did you purposely took that out of context? I mention the high prison population of blacks to compare it to other ethnic groups, specifically white people. If 80 blacks and 20 whites are in jail then that is 80 less potential black anime/manga watchers and 20 less potential white anime/manga watchers. Clearly the anime community suffer a bigger loss from the black ethnic group compare to the white ethnic group. Even if it took you 5-10 hours a week to watch anime doesn't mean everybody can do it. What if they don't have a comfortable seat and/or a manageable attention span? Do you rule them out?
"Well I thought it would be obvious there relatively few black otakus, considering that black people are a minority in the USA..."
"I mention blacks being a minority to give you an idea how low the TOTAL number of black otakus there are. That is to say you are UNLIKELY to find any black otakus."
"As far as the ratio of black anime/manga to non-anime/manga viewers, I would say its probably lower than the white people ratio, based off of income statics and crime rate."
Seems like it's in context to me.. hmm...
Otherwise, it seems that I didn't realize how frivolous your standard for "high and low" was to be defined by such small amounts, as small as 0.8%. My apologies~
If blacks make up around 12% of the American population, which is 38 million.
And 0.8% are imprisoned (This one is inaccurate).
This means, by your accounts, your unlikely to find a black otaku...
Let me put it a different way...
If we use Japan's total pupoulation, not accounting for "non-Japanese".
Their total population is 126 million, 3x as much.
Against the total population of Whites in America, which is 223 million, around 2x as much.
(2010 consensus data)
Is it a 3x difference that's the "determining factor" for a low count? Couldn't I just as easily spin this as, "Your unlikely to find a Japanese Otaku versus an American Otaku"?
Actually, I can, if were only going off population count... But, that was neither your claim nor your proposition. You were going off a combination of African-American population count, income levels along with crime ratios, and mainstream appeal, as your main argument (just the phrases, not anything in actual depth to those claims). As well, easily missed the fact that, by comparison, Japanese are minorities as well, but that doesn't make their "Otaku count" "low"/"few".
As an added measure, that I don't feel like bothering with, account for the population of Africa and (a bit) of the Middle-East. If you want to use the open-ended "context" of the original quote, from your debate with ecchigaijin, that never actually indicates he/she is only regarding blacks only in America, And can very much be regarded as what ecchigaijin was debating, not assuming, but no context is given to this.
"Even if it took you 5-10 hours a week to watch anime doesn't mean everybody can do it" actually... Anime isn't one of those things that varies in duration based on the observer. The duration of an anime is very much consistent. 23-24mins, including the Op/Ed and preview.
"What if they don't have a comfortable seat and/or a manageable attention span? Do you rule them out?" was a joke, but if you want to blow out of proportion a fringe statement, why not apply this to "white people" too? Since, statistically speaking, there are more in the US, almost 7x, by comparison, that would mean, that many more of the White population in America can't "watch anime" in that time span either. And therefore, must not watch anime, since you seem to be indicating that being unable to do either or both equates to not watching anime at all.
SupremeSilver wrote...
Said by the guy who apparently thinks computers and the internet are free...
1) Fictional realism
2) Mistranslation may not matter some viewers but they could destroy culture references like they did with DBZ.
3) Translation may not be easy but it doesn't change the fact that some translations are rather erroneous and it would be better to do some research on Japanese culture to fully appreciate/understand the plot of anime/manga.
Now "who's putting words in who's mouth"? At what point did I say, in my previous post, that "computers and internet is free". You seem to be misinterpreting "inequality in the African-Americans community" as "having no source of income to afford cheap and common luxuries/necessities". (What, do they all live in boxes?) All while completely dismissing my statements regarding television... So proud!
I love when my statement is deconstructed so that the other person can contest my weakest statements while ignoring what they can not debate. Makes discussion so much easier~
To #2~3. Not really, most anime isn't particularly rich in cultural aspects to the point of warranting independent research. For the few Animes that are plot heavy enough too, they are pretty self explanatory in their presentation and reveal of.
DBZ, as far as I know of, is a rather extreme and singular exception from another time. I really don't think you can regard it as relevant anymore. You'll have to use something from within the last 5-10 years.