Hang on, just woke up. Shall break it down, and see if I can't explain myself a little better.
Hey, ho, massive text. Set aside a few minutes of your time, this may take a while
Waar wrote...
Drifter995 wrote...
This entirely.
Although, I'd like to expand on it;
From what she has posted (her 'apology') It seems she has no feeling, no actual regret, and has not come to the realisation of why she was banned, or what she has done wrong.
She has admitted she has done some wrong, but will not expand on that, and will not admit that she has done wrong explicitly. She will keep making apologies that say 'I MAY have done something wrong, and for that I'm sorry' not, 'I HAVE done something wrong, I abused people, I attacked people, I broke the rules in multiple ways, by creating alts, etc etc'
From where I'm sitting, she lacks sincerity in her apology, and is just bullshitting her way through an apology, like the last fifty times.
If she wants my approval, she needs to make a sincere apology, put meaning, put thought, and actually prove she's realised her mistakes, and has learned from them.
After that happens (which I doubt), I propose an undefined probation time (preferably indefinite again) and if she fucks up (again) Ban her again, and keep her the fuck off the forums.
I'm being serious here, if she can break all the fucking rules, and come back as 50 alts, fuck shit up, abuse people, personally attack people, and be a general cunt (breaking more rules) Then, come back scott free.. Why the fuck do we have rules? Why the fuck are there even mods? If she is allowed to have such privilege, why is yoshi not back? Why is mantis not allowed back? What she has done is by far worse than what the others have done collectively.
Honestly, either be consistent with the rules, and how you enforce them, and ban her, and tell her to fucking grow up. Or, let her back, and let mantis and the others back.
Again, this is about her 50th time being considered a chance. The past times have all ended up in her breaking her promise and getting banned. She gave an 'apology' and swore she would be good. That lasted about a good few weeks before she got banned again. Every time.
Every time you (waar) even considers telling her to re-word her bullshit apologies, or banning her for breaking the rules (yet again), she comes back with 20 more alts, calls you a cunt, tells you to kill yourself, calls jacob a cunt, tries her best to break the server (although she seems to lack the know how on how that actually works) and pretty much throws her chance in the toilet. Last time this happened, that happened whilst we were discussing bringing her back. Then she somehow came back under the impression she was allowed back, before being banned again. Now this.
Seriously dude, you need to just man up and get rid of her. She is cancer.
Every time she does this, she gives you an insincere apology, filled with bullshit about how she's 'changed' and then goes and does exactly what she was banned for.
She is literally a child. Nothing is going to get to her, and get her to change, especially if this shit keeps happening. How can you possibly learn a lesson if you keep getting treats when you're meant to be punished?
re-evaluate, sleep on it, then get back to me.
edit; Apologies, got a bit heavy fingered in there, but, point still stands. You've been far too forgiving to her
Also; notice how as soon as you posted 'You have shown no guilt, nor remorse' and suddenly a thread comes up about guilt and remorse? Yet, it still doesn't contain sincerity and/ or specifically admit to guilt, just says that things 'may' have happened. And when questioned on it, she just says 'for things that HAVE happened' doesn't say the whole thing over, and put meaning into it, it's all just another false front to try and sweet talk you into coming back onto the forums.... again.
Going to start off by saying the following statement is in no way meant to indicate where I fall on this matter. that being said this is the internet, and these are words, the amount of "feeling" you perceive has no baring the true amount of responsibility she feels, you're basing the judgement on whether or not she's sincere entirely on your opinion of the person. For example I can say I'm sorry for x and y but there's no way in hell for you to tell just by my words alone if I really mean it. Everyone jumping on the "That didn't feel like a real apology" train is letting biased judgement cloud the issue, some people aren't adept at writing, or less adept with the English language(not saying this is the case).
I have to say, that what you're saying is wrong. I'm not perceiving it as insincere, because of my personal feelings for the accused, I'm saying it, because it's plainly obvious in how she has replied in the thread, how she acts, and this is also going off previous accounts, where the same half assed replies were had, and it shows.
Whilst she is dumb in my opinion, yes. She is smart enough to know what she is doing here, and how to word her 'apologies' and what not, and get the slap on the wrist for the fifth time.
Have you ever considered, that the train is actually people who can read bullshit? She's not less adept with the english langauge, so that doesn't apply. She knows full well what she's doing. She doesn't know
how to apologies, and actually realise what she did was wrong, and take it as a lesson to better herself. I know this, as I have witnessed most of the threads about this, her actions, then the actions that follow (which all follow what she was banned for the previous time), and then coming into the chat, and bragging about it. She knows she can get to you, and get unbanned occasionally, if she says please enough times.
Waar wrote...
Fakku does have rules, but they aren't set in stone to the point where people can't be permitted to rejoin the community after a set amount of time. Yoshii was a special case where Jake was the one who banned him and I guess he took whatever Yoshii did personally, and as you know Jacob is a special case when it comes to bans. Mantis would have been allowed back if he didn't come back and violate the rules every couple of months with a ban evasion(the exact same reason koko wasn't really permitted back). Your advice on being consistent is something I want to pay special attention to though, and it leads me to one question; why? Every case is different, and every moderator punishes differently. I see no reason to change that, people being "perma banned" lose all right to "fair treatment". I'm not saying I don't think standardized moderating would be a good idea but I don't own or run this site.
But, if they aren't set in stone, why use them for one person, and not for the other?
The yoshii case is fair enough in that aspect, as jake.
But, I want to have a look at the mantis case, and why it is so different from the koko case. Mantis came back a few times, and did nothing bad (as did koko, albiet she ended up doing what she normally does after some time), he also asked to come back at one stage, and you said no, shortly after, you let koko back in, after she did more or less, the same thing. Bar the fact mantis necro'd things (which isn't against the rules now) and koko made billions of alts, and came in to abuse you, and everyone else, because she's childish.
So, from where I'm sitting, mantis seems like an angel on the scale of the rule book, compared to koko. But, the rules aren't solid, apparently. Of course moderators take action differently. Everything is subjective. It's subjective on to what point something is considered breaking the rules. You'd get some who ban for just the slightest instance, others who are far more forgiving (like you) in regards to bullshit. As, you enjoy the shit that happens in ib, as it gives us something to do, more or less. That, and from memory, you enjoy a good argument.
As for the those who get 'perma banned' losing all rights to be treated fairly... Why is koko getting treated fairly every time then? Gets banned, breaks more rules to call you and jake cunts, comes back, and then gets banned again, then comes back, and wants to stay on the forums for realsies after being found out, and you decide to see what the public opinion is (which, is more or less giving them a fair judgement), this time, similar deal, you're looking to be persuaded either way, so you can be pushed further to one side on whether to keep banning her, and put up with this bullshit many more times, or just let her run free, and do the same things again, as she does, which is more than likely going to get her banned, and then the cycle will start again anyway, as the previous time showed.
Waar wrote...
She doesn't really need your approval, like last time I'm going to do what I think is best based on my own judgement, all I ask for is your input but please don't take this is anyone begging or pleading. I would appreciate it if people back up whatever I decide in the end but it's not a requirement.
I'm not saying this is my approval, this is my opinion on the matter. My opinion that this happens every time, and it's just getting to the point of 'If we're banned, we should be able to make alts, make a few hate threads, make a new account, pretend to be another newbie, and when found out, beg to stay'
Honestly feel I should go get mantis, and tell him to just get his account to send you a message and say 'Hey, I would like to come back to the forums' If he has an alt, you can't say 'no, that's breaking the rules' after just considering top kok even remotely all these times, who did the exact same thing. THAT would be wildly inconsistent, and would require assessing of the situation either between you and top kok, or something else.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to convince you either way as such, I'm just trying to point out what I've seen, understand what is happening here, and try to get my point across, that it will just keep happening in a nice circle, unless you do something about it, or top kok actually grows up.
I'll back you up with your decision, I may not fully approve of it if you do the same, but, not much I can do either way. No point starting a revolution, as you're not a retarded mod (not saying the ones here are, just saying, it's hard to not get people overly power hungry. I know people have said you're power hungry, whilst you are a tiny bit (in that you find ib 'fun' sometimes), you aren't), nor are you trigger happy, which is good. That and you do your job pretty well from what I've seen. Aside from the falling for koko's charm every time, but we'll get to that.
Waar wrote...
On the point of me being too forgiving: people constantly accuse me of being too harsh, too quick to ban, too much of an intractable dick when it comes to handing out punishment but the second it starts up about a user you guys don't like everyone accuses me of being a care-bear; make up your minds you fickle assholes.
I have yet to see you being seriously harsh, or too quick to ban. You don't ban people unless they blatantly break the rules (as with your post in the whole solidsnake new alt case) or piss you off to the point of wanting to ban them (which is fair enough). I've poked fun at you for being banned once before for quote pyramids, shit happens. I haven't been under the impression you are too harsh, too quick to ban, too much of a dick at all. I don't think many people are, unless they are breaking rules blatantly, and in a position to get banned. Think of it like this; You drive a nice car, and get pulled over. You're nice to the policeman, he's nice to you, he lets you go. Your 'friend' zooms passed, gets pulled over, policeman ask if he knows why he's been pulled over, he replies 'YOU'RE JUST OUT TO FUCKING GET US, YA PIG CUNTS', the policeman sighs, decides to inspect the car, and finds many defectable things. Meanwhile, the driver is throwing constant abuse at him. Now, being in that position, the policeman is sick of his shit, and throws him a fairly big fine, because he is being a douche. Later on, same dude does a burnout, blasts down the road at twice the speed limit, gets pulled over again, same deal.
They get back, and have stories about how the police are massive cunts, and they did nothing wrong.
It's only those who are in the wrong that feel wronged by those in position 80% of the time. The rest is special cases of which those in power ARE actually power hungry, and decide to abuse their power for the sake of it (For example, defecting stock cars)
You may not have defects over in canada though, so that example may be a little questionable in your eyes, but the second part works.
Honestly, all I've seen is you being overly laid back, with a nice 'fuck off, you're annoying' bat. However, every time koko comes back, it seems like she just somehow flatters her eyelashes, and you go 'Oh, well ok then, tehe' as she comes back for the 50th time, and soon after, does the same thing again.
From my seat here, it does look wildly inconsistent, and that she's somehow charming you into letting her out. Inb4 tit pics through inbox (pretty sure she did that at one stage too, actually)
You have to see that it does look like she is getting special attention/ special rules.
Now, if you said to me 'Ok, seriously, it's boring in ib now. She makes it interesting again, with all her bullshit. That's why I keep bringing her back. It gives the oldies something to do in this stale place' I would accept that argument, as, it's right. And, I get a small feeling that's the case here.
Waar wrote...
I'm going to keep reading before I give my opinion on the matter but for now let's say I'm unconvinced either way.
Fair call. As said, not trying to convince you (well, probably am a little bit), just trying to understand what is actually happening, why this keeps happening, and what the dealio is here.
Awrin and reno say hi... Also gravity cat