Naruto VS Luffy

Who wins in an all-out brawl?

All power-ups from both sides are accessible, but restricted to the amount they can be used in the manga

I'd like to say, right off the bat, that Naruto's Kyuubi mode should not be allowed, since he cannot access it by himself (there needs to be something that really pisses him off, like someone dying), and he doesn't even like it, because he could hurt people he cares about.

Now, about the fight - Luffy has Gear 3rd, but it doesn't last long, and I don't think being really big would help much in the fight. Naruto has kunai and throwing shuriken and such, and they would damage Luffy, but Naruto doesn't use them much.

Would Naruto's Rasengan work against Luffy? I think it would, but what if it just made Luffy stretch a lot?

Rasengan shuriken would work against Luffy. Naruto also has Sage mode which he can access at will but as is in the manga he either has to prepare clones before the battle to collect it if he is to use it more then one time. I don't think Luffy would give Naruto much time to stand still and collect the energy to go back into Sage mode.



I would have to give the match to Naruto in the end.

Coming from someone who hates both sides equally, Naruto wins hands down. I really hate it, but if they were to engage in a bloody fight with the sole intention of eliminating both sides from the face of existence, Naruto would continue to exist in the end. Although, if you think about it, Luffy would win as he would no longer exist and Naruto would continue to deprive true ninja of any kind of pride.

I have given this more thought and would the Rasengan Shuriken actually work against Luffy? It destroys chakra points and does massive damage but does Luffy have chakra points? He isn't from the Naruverse so do the rules that apply for Naruto and characters apply for Luffy and Characters? Luffy is no push over. He is one badass dude that can take a lot of damage with a smile on his face.

Lol, pretty much that. Naruto has way too many abilities compared to Luffy. Then again, I've never been much of a one piece fan so I can't tell for sure who'd win. But Naruto seems persistent, has a seemingly unbreakable will to overcome any opponent.. and he's really strong.

Unlike Superman and Goku, I actually know about these two. :D

Luffy's pretty strong. He's immune to blunt damage and I don't think Rasengan would work on him. But kunai knives will probably do the trick. Even if one says that Naruto doesn't use kunais often, if he figured out that's the only way to damage him, he'd use it (Not to mention shurikens). But we also have to take into consideration Luffy's speed. In gear second, he's probably a lot faster than Naruto, and spamming Gum Gum pistol would probably do a good bit of damage on Naruto. I don't think shadow clones would be a big factor except to wear Luffy down, which isn't likely since he took down a thousand troops +, and I'm pretty sure he can mow down Naruto's clones with Gum Gum Gatling.

In the end, I think they're on equal ground. The only thing that'll tip the balance is Kyuubi.

damm thats tough.. I would go for luffy cause he packs more punch
naruto in sage mode would hold his own but I belive luffy would win it would be close tough

I am more of a One Piece fan, so i'll be supporting Luffy here. If you see anything wrong, just say so.

Anyways...

Naruto's Kage Bunshin would probably just be useless against Luffy since he can take them all down with either Gatling or Fireworks or he could avoid them with the one he used against Eneru (Boh, or something). And even the Sexy no Jutsu is totally useless against an idiot like Luffy (the one with Nami's was probably just for the comedic effect). Now the Rasengan Techniques would definitely damage him, but would take a bit less damage since he made of Rubber. If Naruto uses Kuchiyose no Jutsu... Either Luffy uses 3rd Gear or unleashes a barrage of attacks on Normal or 2nd gear. But considering that the frogs are fuckin ninjas, they could avoid Luffy's 3rd Gear since the attack speed on this mode has dropped quite a lot.

Now, about speed. I think Naruto has the upper hand unless Luffy uses 2nd Gear. And I don't know who has the upper hand if Naruto uses Sage Mode. But I don't think Luffy would let Naruto gather Natural energy... unless Naruto offers meat (-_-,)

But on hand-to-hand combat, I personally think that Luffy would have the upper hand, since through his journey, he has experienced countless battles using only his fists. naruto, on the other hand, solely relies on taijutsu as a last resort if their chakra run out. Unless Rock Lee is fighting, I don't think Naruto would stand a chance, especially if Luffy turns on his 2nd Gear.

Now on tactics.... err, I have no idea who has the better one.

Luffy tends to adapt to the situation and surrounding and fight without thinking while Naruto uses tactics and also tends to adapt to the situation and surrounding.

There's also the unknown power of Luffy's, The Haki (google it with One piece. It's a pain to explain this one)

Now their Fighting Spirit/Will. As the Hero, their fighting spirit increases steadily as the fight drags on and they take more damage. Both of them have Friends and Specific Goals that they would fight for to the death. Not to mention that both of them are fuckin thick-headed and would never give up. They are both equal in this one.

Pirates Vs. Ninjas again? Ninjas. It's a no brain-er.

Naruto would definitely win, hands down.

If there were restrictions like Jebus said, "no kyuubi," then it would turn into an endurance match, in which case Luffy would win because he can take a crap load more abuse than Naruto, unless Naruto landed a hit with his Element Rasengan.

So Luffy would only win under the conditions that there is no Kyuubi and no Element Rasengan. Oh, and a non-water battlefield.

they both lose for being on terrible shows.

I definitely think Naruto would win mainly because of his Rasengan ,but hes probly quicker and stronger then Luffy because of him being a ninja, plus Naruto has the possible chance of going into godlymode(kyuubi)...

Light Yagami would own both their asses in less 40 seconds.

I don't think u have all the rights in the world to say this line.. Although I hate Naruto too (Not Luffy)
If I can -Rep u, I will do it.. And also for that person who +Rep this guy is a douche-bag..

---

This is not suppose to be here..

---

Here's what I think.. Luffy will win with his Gear 2nd (cuz Gear 3rd Sucks).. He can use "Soru" and disappear from sight and hit the bitch with his "Jet (Skills)".. Also, Rasen-Shuriken takes too much time too charge..

In during people vote for the character that belongs to the show they like more.

I don't have a right to give my opinion now? bit of an idiot aren't you?

The point of this thread is to see the ONE character who wins the battle.. If u don't feel like answering then get the fuck outta this thread..
If u wanna say u don't like them both then say so instead of insulting the show.. umm, bit of an idiot aren't you?

Sorry to say but I felt offended as one of the fan for One Piece..

PS: Keep on -Rep me, It's nice..

Dude, you're taking this shit way to seriously. This thread was gonna turn into a fanboy wars anyways. It's inevitable when it comes to this stuff.

each of they are strong after all
naruto have kyuubi inside
luffy have gear2nd and 3rd
but still naruto can pushing luffy with rasengan
but luffy can use gomu2 pistol so the winner is naruto
luffy dont have inner side

Hell Yeah I take this seriously, One Piece is one of the best Anime Series I watched.. (Opinion)