WHO DID THIS TERRIBLE THING
0
ShaggyJebus wrote...
People will still spam, trying to get rep. I imagine there would be a lot of threads consisting of nothing more than, "If you rep me, I'll rep you." That, and they would spam by making countless threads asking why they can't get into the User Uploads section anymore and bitching about not being able to get in there anymore.Agreed, I was part of a forum where the rep was used and yeah, it was pretty much the Rep me & I Rep you. People will find one way or another to abuse things.
Jacob wrote...
Remember when the site when down for 24 hours? Well it was because we had a copyright claim from some hentai publishers in the United States.O_O Wow...insane, that fast!
It's really difficult to think of some kind of solution that wouldn't put more work into the uploaders end while at the same time make things more secure and stay up. I would have thought Megarotic to keep anything up too. Besides getting things via irc or from personal webspace/torrent, I can't see a proper solution.
0
Yushi wrote...
The Rep idea, while could be valid, not everyone is great enough to get many rep points *points to self*This site is getting bigger and bigger. And i believe we will need more Mods to manage / control the forums, mostly. What i might suggest is that we create a title ''Fakku Member'' Who will be given to member who have gain trust, from Mods / Admin and they could give permission for them to use the ''User Upload'' section.Promote who we beleive won't start reporting stuff. Its someway to get some control on report stuff...
This way, we can avoid the SPAM bullcrap, cuz if your just spamming useless post, that avoids mods to promote you to use that section.
But it requires insane amount of work, that not many people would do.
this seems like an alright idea, but for the people (myself) who just use one forum for general discussion purposes, there is no way to tell if he/she would report links or not.
0
an further evolved idea of the rep barrier would be a adjustable rep barrier.
for example you want to create a thread and you only want people with 10+ rep to enter it.
So every uploader would be free to choose if he wants a barrier or not.
still there would be the problem with spamming so
you could also come up with the idea to set up a password for a thread.
like an option when you create the thread where you anable password security and insert a password.
then the uploader only hands out the password to people he thinks are trustful via pm.
(well thats like the provide links only via pm but a little bit easier to handle)
this way you could avoid spamming the forum and the responsibilities for the thread would belong to the uploader himself
for example you want to create a thread and you only want people with 10+ rep to enter it.
So every uploader would be free to choose if he wants a barrier or not.
still there would be the problem with spamming so
you could also come up with the idea to set up a password for a thread.
like an option when you create the thread where you anable password security and insert a password.
then the uploader only hands out the password to people he thinks are trustful via pm.
(well thats like the provide links only via pm but a little bit easier to handle)
this way you could avoid spamming the forum and the responsibilities for the thread would belong to the uploader himself
0
Eranox wrote...
an further evolved idea of the rep barrier would be a adjustable rep barrier.for example you want to create a thread and you only want people with 10+ rep to enter it.
So every uploader would be free to choose if he wants a barrier or not.
still there would be the problem with spamming so
you could also come up with the idea to set up a password for a thread.
like an option when you create the thread where you anable password security and insert a password.
then the uploader only hands out the password to people he thinks are trustful via pm.
(well thats like the provide links only via pm but a little bit easier to handle)
this way you could avoid spamming the forum and the responsibilities for the thread would belong to the uploader himself
I think that password protected threads is a decent idea. But there's always the little bitches who'll spam the forums and any well-known uploader's inbox.
You could report the spammers and ban them but I guess there'd just be more to take their place.
Idiocy is like a virus.
0
Garden of Madness wrote...
Eranox wrote...
an further evolved idea of the rep barrier would be a adjustable rep barrier.for example you want to create a thread and you only want people with 10+ rep to enter it.
So every uploader would be free to choose if he wants a barrier or not.
still there would be the problem with spamming so
you could also come up with the idea to set up a password for a thread.
like an option when you create the thread where you anable password security and insert a password.
then the uploader only hands out the password to people he thinks are trustful via pm.
(well thats like the provide links only via pm but a little bit easier to handle)
this way you could avoid spamming the forum and the responsibilities for the thread would belong to the uploader himself
I think that password protected threads is a decent idea. But there's always the little bitches who'll spam the forums and any well-known uploader's inbox.
You could report the spammers and ban them but I guess there'd just be more to take their place.
Idiocy is like a virus.
but at least it would keep them from spamming the forum I hope, since no one would care about them and the only person who is able to grant them access is the uploader himself.
and as for the inbox spam, you could also implement a function that only people you allow to can send you pms, like by setting an option in your profile to only get messages form people with a certain number of post or rep.
but at least all this is up to jacob and all the other admins and there are only two options either they implement it or not.
0
Eranox wrote...
Garden of Madness wrote...
Eranox wrote...
an further evolved idea of the rep barrier would be a adjustable rep barrier.for example you want to create a thread and you only want people with 10+ rep to enter it.
So every uploader would be free to choose if he wants a barrier or not.
still there would be the problem with spamming so
you could also come up with the idea to set up a password for a thread.
like an option when you create the thread where you anable password security and insert a password.
then the uploader only hands out the password to people he thinks are trustful via pm.
(well thats like the provide links only via pm but a little bit easier to handle)
this way you could avoid spamming the forum and the responsibilities for the thread would belong to the uploader himself
I think that password protected threads is a decent idea. But there's always the little bitches who'll spam the forums and any well-known uploader's inbox.
You could report the spammers and ban them but I guess there'd just be more to take their place.
Idiocy is like a virus.
but at least it would keep them from spamming the forum I hope, since no one would care about them and the only person who is able to grant them access is the uploader himself.
and as for the inbox spam, you could also implement a function that only people you allow to can send you pms, like by setting an option in your profile to only get messages form people with a certain number of post or rep.
but at least all this is up to jacob and all the other admins and there are only two options either they implement it or not.
that sounds like an alright idea i suppose...Well..Just bring it to Suggestion and feedback section to hear what'll they say about this...Not everyone enters the random section anyway...
0
Shinichi Miyamoto wrote...
that sounds like an alright idea i suppose...Well..Just bring it to Suggestion and feedback section to hear what'll they say about this...Not everyone enters the random section anyway...I will do so but I doubt that it will be implemented.
DONE
https://www.fakku.net/viewtopic.php?t=12372
lets see what the admins will say about this.
0
There is always the possibility that these link reporters are being paid (in monetary terms) to report their "findings". They could be anyone, and I would think they are likely to be people who have no interest in hentai.
0
Gambler wrote...
There is always the possibility that these link reporters are being paid (in monetary terms) to report their "findings". They could be anyone, and I would think they are likely to be people who have no interest in hentai.If that's the case, it could turn into an epidemic.
0
Waar
FAKKU Moderator
i believe the rep idea is the best of all of these, though i'm not sure how fair it is... rep was really hard to gain when I had none it only seems to flow in after i had many. (or maybe i just became more funny over time?)
0
Shit Happens, and I think that users Registered for a month and above. Make people wait patiently, for a month to get to the UA section.
0
Angelus Lapsus wrote...
Shit Happens, and I think that users Registered for a month and above. Make people wait patiently, for a month to get to the UA section.This is a good idea. I bet most of them assholes create ID solely to get their hands on the user upload section as fast as possible, and then mess with it. Give them nothing in the first months, and the leechers will go "wtf where's the hentai?" and leave, while good users who really want to join the community stay active and eventually got the reward they deserved.
0
I'm fairly new, long time lurker though, but I think a lot of good points have been brought up. I think people should start off with shaggyjebus's idea of just changing the file names of what you upload. Such as with his idea of taking "Wife with Wife" and using winrar [or others] to make stuff1.rar and stuff2.rar files. This would eliminate those who use google hacks or file share search engines for their company's search and destroy missions. Though that's something the uploaders themselves need to implement and not something that fakku could or even should police.
On the fakku side, I think that hibia's ideas over here would help in catching who is looking at the links, and then there can be temp banned to check and see who is really reporting the links. But then again this would be a nightmare to impliment.
Fakku could also impliment a waiting period as previously stated. Many forums out there have waiting periods for things as simple as making a thread so I doubt that this would be anything hard for the real users to wait for.
Now with the previous you then could implement a post requirement. But a post requirement alone would only end in mass spamming rather than thoughtful* posts. So it probably would be best to say, have a one month registration period with at least 20 posts, and no warnings for spam by the mods. This way they know that spam will just make it take longer to get in. And it can also be a punishment for those who constantly spam the forums to be kicked out of the user uploads as a first level deterrent.
On the fakku side, I think that hibia's ideas over here would help in catching who is looking at the links, and then there can be temp banned to check and see who is really reporting the links. But then again this would be a nightmare to impliment.
Fakku could also impliment a waiting period as previously stated. Many forums out there have waiting periods for things as simple as making a thread so I doubt that this would be anything hard for the real users to wait for.
Now with the previous you then could implement a post requirement. But a post requirement alone would only end in mass spamming rather than thoughtful* posts. So it probably would be best to say, have a one month registration period with at least 20 posts, and no warnings for spam by the mods. This way they know that spam will just make it take longer to get in. And it can also be a punishment for those who constantly spam the forums to be kicked out of the user uploads as a first level deterrent.