Kaimax wrote...
LOL, like said, somewhat like a troll.
since they're raking up on the stuff that the TLteam did and expect for free, now JAST has the potential to rake off more money.
and like said it would be bad if they decided to go dumb and actually use their own script.
From my "Economic perspective" it's kinda unethical and dirty to use this method of licensing.
"Oh, let's just wait and buy the license for it when it's done, we get more the money while we didn't work on anything." kind of dirty.
In the end I respect mangagamers more just because they do their own translations from the start. I would react differently if they cooperated with TLwiki from the early stage of the translation.
In the end this will also affect the release date. Just like what happened with Sumaga. Sumaga was so close to a finished translation, which if it wasn't licensed we already played it by now. Once again, they (read: JAST and NITRO+) opted to do Demonbane which has zero translation at that moment First, while doing nothing to the Sumaga translations.
I know that, "we can't do much if it involves licensing" but JAST's move is just dirty. In the end JAST will receive more money than the TLteam if they didn't have any royalties. It's just like a novelist paying someone to make them a novel.
People (read:people that doesn't frequent TLsites) that buy it will remember it's game by JAST not by TLwiki.
@nekomimiko
Personal question, how would you feel if you got the same treatment on your Katahane Project?
Oh I didn't really meant that much but well lol.
Talking about *That method of licensing* in the end it's just business, what's wrong with business wanting to make money with the most profitable route available? JAST has the ability to publish, and they offered the Osadai's staff some money to buy their scripts. And they
accepted, knowing that it would pull their release date further, and whats wrong with that? WHat's so wrong about getting translated official english release with the most fastest and efficient and profitable way possible for a company that would benefit the creators and the translation team?
But yeah, if it's crediting the right people. Yes, JAST would be the one get credited, but didnt you see the Osadai's staff already
*sold* that privilege to JAST anyway? No problem here I'm sure.
All parties Alcot+Osadai Staff+JAST is happy, where's the unethical?
But I'm half sure that this wouldn't become another Demonbane issue, the engine is Kirikiri so they wouldn't have problems like Demonbane. I wouldn't even be surprised if this get released before Demonbane does.
Ethical or not on this seemed to be subjective and different from my view to yours, I don't think it's unethical. But does it suck? Yeah, it does to people anticipating it to be released in the couple few months and then suddenly told they have to wait longer, but
that's it, is there anything else that is bad? Nothing else that I can see.
(I'm not the one waiting so I'm not mad! Osadai is pretty crappy <-- biased)
About the crediting off topic,
Besides, many of the people dont care who does it, as long as there is. You and many others kept crediting Tlwiki like just now, but tlwiki is not a group like Amaterasu/Yandere/Dakkodango. It is a place for people to host projects openly. Many projects does not have the same members, so why credit a website? Which made what you said rather ironic.
Individuals should be credited for what they done for free, but apparently nobody cares Not caring at the individual who does it anyway. I bet my butt majority of the people here don't even care anyway, as long as they have their shiny translation in one way or another. It's the typical "I deserve it" attitude I'm sure you're familiar with.
I wonder if most of the people know exactly who did their Sharin no Kuni, their Saya no Uta, etc. I wonder if they actually know the editors who work their ass off beautifying engrish into readable english? Some of them surely, if they follow and appreciate, but most doesn't.
End result, crediting isn't worth any crap in VN translation. People who care about the VNTL scene is just a small circle.
For your question
I honestly can't imagine that, but I don't think it's something that bad to the extent you have to use the word "treatment". From what I gathered, nobody really cares much of Katahane anyway, and most of the people who play it wouldn't even give a shit who does it anyway. All I want was to get this cute game out available to people who can't read japanese. So yeah I'll take fifty bucks for it to be licensed even. At least the creators are earning money!! That sounds like a redemption for me who pirates the hell out of everything. But the end product is the same, it will get released, and i'll be happy that I had made it possible. Getting it licensed is just little stone in the way.
A little delay for the people who doesn't care at all who does it.
A nice expensive dinner for myself who spent 6 months on this thinggy, and knowing that I actually helped the creators a favor. (You know this feel, you buy stuff from your favourite company too right? I would, but I dont have the excess money.)
I cant say for sure but I believe the staff who sold their script think the same way too.
Oh hey, one thing slipped my mind that I didnt mention that JAST was pretty shitty at. Previously before the announcement, Jlist (Which is also JAST) has promoted to sell the original Japanese Osadai game with "BUY IT ENGLISH PATCH COMMIN SOON", then this happens. That's pretty sucky and I hope Peter payne snuck it up and give people a refund for false advertisement.